The mouthguard that protects best is the one a player actually keeps in, at training as well as on game day. For most people playing contact sport, that is a guard made from a scan or impression of their own teeth, because it fits snugly, stays put without clenching and makes talking and breathing easier. A boil-and-bite guard from the chemist is a reasonable stopgap, and any guard is far better than none.
This article compares the three kinds of mouthguard, what the research does and does not show about them, and what a damaged front tooth can mean in the years that follow.
Mouthguards substantially cut the risk of mouth injuries
Sport accounts for up to a third of all injuries to the mouth and face, according to a 2019 systematic review and meta-analysis in Sports Medicine (Knapik and colleagues). Pooling 12 cohort studies, the review found that people who did not wear mouthguards had about 2.3 times the risk of orofacial injury compared with those who did. The studies varied a lot in quality and design, but the direction was consistent, and the authors concluded mouthguards should be used wherever there is a real risk of injury to the face.
Concussion is a different question. The same review found only a modest, statistically uncertain effect. A larger 2023 systematic review in the British Journal of Sports Medicine (Eliason and colleagues) pooled more recent studies and found fewer concussions among mouthguard wearers in collision sports, with an incidence rate ratio of 0.74, roughly a quarter fewer. That is encouraging, but a mouthguard is not concussion protection on its own. Rules, tackling technique and proper return-to-play decisions also matter.
Three types, from cheapest to most closely fitted
Stock guards
These come pre-formed in a few sizes and are worn straight from the packet. Because they are not shaped to the teeth, they sit loosely, and the player has to bite down to hold them in place. That makes speaking and breathing harder, and players tend to take them out. They are better than nothing in an emergency, but not a good choice for regular sport.
Boil-and-bite guards
These are softened in hot water and then bitten into so the material moulds roughly to the teeth. The fit is much better than a stock guard, and for casual or low-contact sport a well-moulded one can be adequate. Common problems are uneven thickness where the teeth pressed through the softened material, short edges that do not reach the back teeth, and a fit that loosens as the guard is chewed or reshaped. Follow the packet instructions carefully and replace the guard once it no longer grips the teeth.
Custom-made guards
A custom guard starts with a digital scan or impression of the teeth. A dental laboratory forms layers of mouthguard material over a model of the teeth to a planned thickness, extends the guard to cover the back teeth, and finishes the edges so they sit comfortably against the gums. The result clips onto the teeth without the player needing to bite to hold it.
The Australian Dental Association's sports mouthguard factsheet says dentists recommend custom-fitted guards, describing them as offering the highest level of protection, and notes that store-bought guards often fit poorly and can affect speech and breathing.

What custom guards do better, and where the evidence is thin
Custom guards clearly fit better and are more comfortable, and players are more likely to keep wearing a guard that is comfortable. Whether they prevent more injuries than a well-fitted boil-and-bite is less certain, because few studies have compared the two head to head in real play. It is fair to say a custom guard removes most of the fit and comfort problems that lead to guards being left in the kit bag.
| Boil-and-bite | Custom-made | |
|---|---|---|
| How it is fitted | Moulded at home in hot water | Made by a lab from a scan or impression |
| Fit and retention | Variable; may need biting to stay in | Snug; stays in while talking and breathing |
| Thickness | Can thin where the teeth press through | Controlled during manufacture |
| Coverage | Often stops short of the back teeth | Planned to cover the back teeth |
| Lifespan | Until it loosens or is chewed out of shape | Longer for adults; growing children need remakes |
| Best suited to | Casual sport or a short-term stopgap | Regular contact or collision sport |
A damaged front tooth can mean decades of dental care
The injuries mouthguards help prevent include chipped and broken teeth, teeth pushed out of position, knocked-out teeth, split lips and cuts to the tongue. The cost of a lost or badly broken front tooth tends to come back again over a lifetime, because repairs eventually need maintenance or replacement.
Typical market ranges for the treatment involved are below. These are general Australian ranges, not Lumi fees, and the actual cost depends on the injury.
| Treatment after a sports injury | Typical market range |
|---|---|
| Composite bonding to repair a chipped tooth | $250 to $800 per tooth |
| Root canal treatment if the nerve is damaged | About $1,000 (front tooth) to $3,000 (molar) |
| Crown to protect a heavily broken tooth | $1,500 to $2,500 |
| Three-unit bridge to replace a lost tooth | $3,500 to $6,500 |
| Single implant with crown to replace a lost tooth | $4,000 to $7,000 |
Teenagers face an extra problem. Dental implants are generally not placed until the jaws have finished growing, because an implant does not move with the growing jaw the way a natural tooth does. A young person who loses a front tooth may therefore need a temporary replacement for some years before an implant is possible. Our dental implant cost guide explains what goes into implant treatment.
If a tooth is knocked out
For an adult tooth, handle it by the crown, not the root. If it is dirty, rinse it briefly in milk or saline. Put it back in its socket as soon as possible, ideally within 15 minutes. If you cannot, keep it in milk or saline, or in the mouth inside the cheek for an older child or adult. Avoid water and never let it dry out. See a dentist immediately; the outlook is poor once the root has been dry for over 60 minutes. A knocked-out baby tooth should never be put back; see a dentist as soon as possible.
Children, growth and braces
Children's mouths change quickly as baby teeth fall out and adult teeth come through, so a guard that fitted well one season may not fit the next. Bring the mouthguard to check-ups so the dentist or oral health therapist (OHT) can see whether it still seats properly. A custom guard often needs remaking as new teeth erupt.
For children and adults in braces, a guard needs room for the brackets and wires, and it may need adjusting or remaking as the teeth move. Moulding a boil-and-bite directly over braces can make it grip the brackets and be hard to remove. Ask the dentist or your orthodontic provider which design suits the current stage of treatment. If your child has not yet had a first dental visit, our guide to a child's first dental visit covers what happens.
Getting the most out of a mouthguard
- Wear it at training as well as in games. The ADA factsheet recommends both.
- Practise wearing it at home for short periods before the season, so speaking and breathing feel normal.
- Clean it with cool water and liquid hand soap, and store it in a protective case.
- Keep it away from boiling water and heat, such as direct sun or a hot car, which can warp it, and do not chew it.
- Replace it if it is cracked, torn, chewed thin or loose.
A sports mouthguard is different from a night guard for grinding, which is made from harder material for a different job. If you clench or grind, our articles on bruxism and night guards for teeth grinding explain the options.
Questions players and parents ask
Which sports need a mouthguard?
The ADA recommends a mouthguard for all children and adults playing contact sports, and also for non-contact sports with a high risk of mouth and tooth injury. Think rugby league and union, AFL, hockey, boxing and martial arts, but also basketball, netball, soccer and skateboarding, where elbows, balls and falls cause injuries.
Top teeth or both?
Most sports guards cover the upper teeth only. Some combat sports use a guard covering both jaws. The dentist can recommend a design for your sport.
Does health insurance help with the cost?
Many extras policies include a benefit for custom mouthguards, but it varies by fund and level of cover. The Commonwealth Ombudsman's private health information notes general dental waiting periods are commonly about 2 months and major dental commonly 12 months, though each fund sets its own. Check with your fund before booking. At Lumi, health fund claims can be processed on the spot via HICAPS.
Mouthguards at Lumi
Lumi Dental makes custom sports mouthguards, and our 3D intraoral scanner means many patients can have a scan instead of impression putty. Book before the season starts so the guard is ready for the first training session. See our general dentistry page or our current offers to arrange a visit in Melrose Park.
Sources
- Knapik JJ, Hoedebecke BL, Rogers GG, Sharp MA, Marshall SW. Effectiveness of mouthguards for the prevention of orofacial injuries and concussions in sports: systematic review and meta-analysis. Sports Medicine, 2019. PubMed
- Eliason PH, et al. Prevention strategies and modifiable risk factors for sport-related concussions and head impacts: a systematic review and meta-analysis. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2023. PubMed
- Australian Dental Association. Sports mouthguards factsheet (teeth.org.au).
- Commonwealth Ombudsman. Private health insurance waiting periods (privatehealth.gov.au).








