Book Online

All health funds accepted · Payment plans available, humm from $0 deposit · CDBS bulk billing

All health funds accepted · Payment plans available, humm from $0 deposit · CDBS bulk billing

Book online

Clinical photographs being taken in the photo room at Lumi Dental

THE LUMI BLOG

Cold sores vs mouth ulcers: how to tell the difference (and when to see a dentist)

How to tell a contagious cold sore from a non-contagious mouth ulcer, what helps each one heal, and when a sore in or around the mouth should be checked.

Dr James Tran, dentist at Lumi Dental Melrose Park

Dr James Tran

May 26, 2026 · Patient Education · 10 min read

The most practical reason to work out which sore you have is contagion. A cold sore is caused by a virus and can pass to a partner, a child or a newborn baby, while an ordinary mouth ulcer cannot be caught by anyone. The treatments differ too, so a cream bought for one does little for the other.

Most people can tell the two apart at home within a minute or so, using where the sore sits, how it started and what it looks like. The sections below cover each condition in turn, what helps while it heals, and the point at which any sore in or around the mouth should be checked by a dentist or GP.

One is a virus, the other is an inflammatory sore

Cold sores come from the herpes simplex virus, usually type 1 (HSV-1). The NHMRC's Staying Healthy guidance notes that about 8 in 10 people have been infected with the virus by the time they are adults, mostly through ordinary contact in childhood. Many never notice a sore. In others the virus lies quiet in the nerves of the face and flares up from time to time, which is why a cold sore so often returns to the same patch of lip.

Mouth ulcers, also called canker sores or recurrent aphthous stomatitis, are not infectious at all. Their exact cause is still not known. A 2015 guideline for dental practitioners by Tarakji and colleagues in the Journal of International Oral Health lists hormonal changes, trauma, medicines, food sensitivity, nutritional deficiency, stress and tobacco among the factors linked to them, and reports that they affect up to a quarter of the general population.

Where it sits usually settles the question

Cold sores form on the outside: the lip, the border where lip meets skin, and sometimes the skin under the nose or on the chin. Mouth ulcers form on the soft, moist lining inside the mouth, such as the inner cheek, the inside of the lip, the sides or underside of the tongue and the floor of the mouth.

The inner edge of the lip is the one place where the two can be confused. Someone having their very first herpes infection, often a young child who is unwell with a fever, can get sores inside the mouth as well. Recurrent cold sores in adults, though, usually return to the outer lip. If you are an adult who gets cold sores and a single sore appears on the inside of your cheek, an ulcer is far more likely.

Cold soreMouth ulcer
CauseHerpes simplex virus, usually type 1Not fully understood; not an infection
Usual siteOuter lip and the skin around itInner cheek, inner lip, tongue, floor of the mouth
First signTingling, itching or burning before anything showsOften noticed only when it stings with food or brushing
LookA cluster of small blisters that weep, then crustA round or oval sore with a yellow or grey base and a red rim, no crust
ContagiousYesNo
Typical healingUsually within about 10 daysAbout 10 to 14 days for the common small type

A cold sore usually announces itself with a tingle

Many people feel a cold sore before they see it. The skin on one small spot starts to itch, tingle or burn, often for a day or so. Small fluid-filled blisters then appear, sometimes merging into one larger blister. Over the next few days they break, weep and dry into a crust, and the skin underneath heals. The Better Health Channel says the crust usually falls off after about 10 days, and cold sores do not cause permanent damage to the skin unless the scab is picked or the blisters are broken.

The blisters and weeping stage carry the most virus, but the virus can also spread when no sore is visible. Picking at the crust slows healing and risks carrying the virus to your fingers or eyes.

Common triggers listed by the Better Health Channel include emotional or physical stress, feverish illnesses such as flu, menstruation, and exposure to strong sun or wind. Some people notice that a long dental appointment, with the lips stretched for a while, sets one off. If that has happened to you, tell your dentist or OHT before the visit so it can be planned around.

Treat a cold sore at the first tingle

Antiviral creams from the pharmacy, aciclovir being the familiar one, work best when started early. The Better Health Channel notes that aciclovir cream works best when applied at the earliest stage, ideally as soon as the tingling begins. Once the sore has crusted, a cream adds little. Pharmacists can also supply some antiviral tablets for cold sores without a prescription, and a GP can prescribe others.

For people who get frequent or severe outbreaks, a GP may talk about taking antiviral tablets for a longer stretch to prevent them. A Cochrane review by Chi and colleagues (2015), covering 32 trials, found that long-term oral antivirals can prevent cold sores, though the benefit was small. The same review found no evidence that antiviral creams prevent recurrences, and no evidence that lysine supplements help, despite their popularity. Sunscreen prevented cold sores triggered by artificial ultraviolet light in two trials, but one trial in real sunlight found no clear effect, so a lip balm with SPF is reasonable sun protection rather than a proven preventive.

Paracetamol or ibuprofen can ease the throbbing, used within the dose on the packet. Cold sore patches do not treat the virus, but some people find they make the sore less noticeable and stop them touching it.

Keeping a cold sore to yourself

While a sore is active, avoid kissing and oral sex, and keep cups, cutlery, lip balm, towels and razors to yourself. Wash your hands after touching the area and before putting in contact lenses.

Two situations need a doctor rather than a pharmacy. The first is any cold sore near the eye: the Better Health Channel advises seeking immediate medical attention, because herpes in the eye can cause corneal ulcers that damage sight. The second is a newborn baby. Babies and people with weakened immune systems are at greater risk of severe infection, and an infection in a newborn should be managed by a doctor. If you have a sore, avoid kissing babies until it has fully healed.

Mouth ulcers come in three forms

The 2015 guideline by Tarakji and colleagues describes three types of aphthous ulcer.

Minor ulcers account for about 85% of cases. They are shallow, usually around 4 to 5 mm and under 1 cm across, appear one to five at a time on the soft lining of the mouth, and tend to heal within 10 to 14 days without scarring.

Major ulcers make up roughly 10 to 15%. They are larger than 10 mm, deeper, can last weeks to months and often leave a scar. They favour the lips, tongue and soft palate and can make eating and swallowing painful.

Herpetiform ulcers are the least common, about 5 to 10%. Despite the name they have nothing to do with the herpes virus. They appear as crops of many tiny ulcers, 1 to 2 mm each, that may join into larger raw areas, and each crop lasts about one to two weeks.

Why some people keep getting ulcers

A one-off ulcer is often explained by an injury: a bitten cheek, a scrape from a corn chip, a hot food burn, a toothbrush slip or a brace wire. When ulcers keep turning up in the same place, there is often something there causing it, such as a chipped tooth, a rough filling edge or a denture that rubs. Finding and smoothing that edge is usually a quick job for a dentist.

Toothpaste can play a part for some people. A systematic review by Alli and colleagues in the Journal of Oral Pathology and Medicine (2019), pooling small crossover trials, found that toothpaste free of sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS, the foaming agent) reduced the number, duration and pain of ulcers in people prone to them. The authors called for better trials, but switching to an SLS-free toothpaste that still contains fluoride is a low-risk thing to try.

Frequent ulcers can also be linked to the body as a whole. The same dental guideline recommends that people with persistent ulcers have blood tests for iron, vitamin B12 and folate, and that coeliac disease be tested for where the history suggests it. Ulcers together with bowel symptoms, joint pain, skin rashes, genital sores or unexplained weight loss are worth raising with your GP. There is more on this in our article on coeliac disease and the mouth.

Easing an ulcer while it heals

Most small ulcers settle on their own, so the aim is comfort. Pharmacy gels and mouth rinses containing a local anaesthetic or antiseptic can take the edge off pain before meals. Many people find a warm salt-water rinse soothing. For a while, go easy on very acidic, spicy or sharp-edged foods, which sting and can scrape the sore open again, and use a soft toothbrush.

For large, frequent or slow-healing ulcers, a dentist or doctor may prescribe a steroid paste or mouthwash that is applied to the ulcer to calm the inflammation. Ulcers linked to a medical condition are managed with the relevant doctor or a specialist in oral medicine. Our separate guide to mouth ulcers and their causes goes into these options further.

Any sore that lasts three weeks needs checking

Cold sores and ordinary ulcers heal. A sore in or around the mouth that has not healed, or has changed, within three weeks should be looked at by a dentist or GP, because mouth cancer can at first look like a stubborn ulcer. It is not likely to be cancer, but it is not something to watch at home.

See someone sooner if a sore:

  • feels firm or hard underneath when you press around it, or has a raised, rolled edge
  • sits on the side or underside of the tongue or the floor of the mouth and has no obvious cause
  • comes with a lump in the neck, numbness or unusual bleeding in the mouth, or a red or white patch nearby (signs Cancer Council lists for mouth cancer)
  • is a cold sore near the eye, or is spreading rather than healing
  • comes with fever and feeling unwell, or appears in someone with a weakened immune system

A firm base is the feature dentists pay most attention to. The Tarakji guideline describes hardness at the edge of an ulcer, known as induration, as characteristic of cancer rather than an ordinary ulcer, which is why we feel around a sore as well as look at it. Our article on oral cancer screening explains what that examination involves.

Dentist in navy scrubs, mask and gloves working in the mouth of a young patient lying back in a dental chair
A dental visit lets the sore be examined by touch as well as by eye, and lets any sharp edges nearby be found.

At Lumi Dental, a check of a sore that will not heal includes looking at and feeling the area, checking the glands in the neck and looking for anything in the mouth that could be rubbing. We can take clinical photographs so the area can be compared at a follow-up visit. Depending on what we find, the next step may be smoothing a tooth or filling, a review in a week or two, blood tests through your GP, or referral to a specialist for a biopsy.

Common questions

Can I kiss someone if I have a mouth ulcer?

Yes. Mouth ulcers are not infectious. It is cold sores that spread through kissing and close contact.

Should I keep my dental appointment if I have a cold sore?

Ring us first. A routine check-up or clean can usually wait until the sore has healed, which is kinder to your lip and reduces the chance of spreading the virus. If you have pain or a dental emergency, we will still see you.

Are cold sores the same as genital herpes?

They are caused by related viruses. Most cold sores are caused by HSV-1, usually caught in childhood through everyday contact such as a kiss from a relative. Either type can occasionally infect the other site through oral sex, which is one more reason to avoid it while a sore is active.

Why does my ulcer always come back in the same spot?

Often because something in that spot keeps catching the lining of your mouth, such as a sharp tooth edge, a worn filling, a wisdom tooth or a brace. A dentist or OHT can usually find it during a check-up.

If you have a sore that has not healed within three weeks, keeps coming back, or you are simply not sure what it is, book an appointment and we will take a look. For a sore with severe pain or swelling, our dental emergency guide covers what to do in the meantime. Lumi Dental is at Melrose Central in Melrose Park, with free undercover parking.

Sources: Better Health Channel: Cold sores; NHMRC Staying Healthy: Cold sores; Tarakji B and colleagues, Guideline for the diagnosis and treatment of recurrent aphthous stomatitis for dental practitioners, Journal of International Oral Health, 2015; Chi CC and colleagues, Interventions for prevention of herpes simplex labialis (cold sores on the lips), Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2015; Alli BY and colleagues, Effect of sodium lauryl sulfate on recurrent aphthous stomatitis: a systematic review, Journal of Oral Pathology and Medicine, 2019; Cancer Council: Head and neck cancer symptoms.

Dr James Tran, dentist at Lumi Dental, Melrose Park

Written by Dr James Tran

Dr James Tran (BDent, University of Sydney; Graduate Diploma in Oral Implants) is a general dentist at Lumi Dental in Melrose Park. The team writes these articles to give clear, evidence-based dental information to help you make informed decisions about your care.

Inside Lumi Dental, Melrose Park

New patients

Your first visit is $149

A full 60 minute first visit with a check-up, clean, X-rays and a treatment plan. Usually $654, offer ends 31 December 2026. With most health funds there is no gap.

Open Monday to Saturday, and until 9:30pm on Thursdays. Free undercover parking at Melrose Central.