Book Online

All health funds accepted · Payment plans available, humm from $0 deposit · CDBS bulk billing

All health funds accepted · Payment plans available, humm from $0 deposit · CDBS bulk billing

Book online

The waiting lounge at Lumi Dental

THE LUMI BLOG

Silver diamine fluoride stain: how families decide

What surveys show about how parents and children feel about the black stain from silver diamine fluoride, whether potassium iodide or a filling can reduce it, and what to ask.

Dr James Tran, dentist at Lumi Dental Melrose Park

Dr James Tran

November 17, 2026 · Children's Dentistry · 8 min read

In parent surveys in the United States and Italy, about two in three parents found the black stain from silver diamine fluoride (SDF) acceptable on a back tooth, and in a Spanish survey about four in ten did. On a front tooth, the figure was below one in three in all three surveys. The other strong influence in these studies was what the alternative treatment would involve for the child.

SDF is a liquid painted onto decay to help stop it, without drilling or a needle. It stains the decayed area black, and that stain is long lasting. This article looks at what research shows about how parents and children feel about the stain, whether it can be reduced or covered, and the questions worth asking before treatment. For how SDF works and how often it is reapplied, see our articles on silver diamine fluoride and how often SDF is reapplied.

Back teeth and front teeth are judged very differently

A study of 120 parents in the New York City area showed them photographs of SDF-treated teeth. Two thirds (67.5%) judged staining on back teeth to be acceptable in appearance, compared with 29.7% for front teeth (Crystal and colleagues, Journal of the American Dental Association, 2017).

Studies elsewhere found the same pattern with different numbers. In Italy, 65.4% of 234 parents rated staining on back teeth acceptable or somewhat acceptable, against 19.3% for front teeth (Cappiello and colleagues, International Journal of Paediatric Dentistry, 2025). Parents surveyed in Spain (264 parents) were less accepting, at 41.8% for back teeth and 17.2% for front teeth (Cappiello and colleagues, Scientific Reports, 2025). A 2026 systematic review of 126 studies on non-aesthetic treatments for decay in children, including SDF, found a median parental acceptance of SDF on back baby molars of 69.9%, with a very wide range between studies, and many of the included studies were rated at moderate or high risk of bias (Reinhard and colleagues, Acta Stomatologica Croatica, 2026).

Acceptance rises when the alternative is harder on the child

The same parents who dislike the stain often change their view when they picture the other options. In the New York City area study, when the alternative was treatment under general anaesthesia, acceptance rose to 68.5% for back teeth and 60.3% for front teeth. As the number of behaviour barriers to a normal filling increased, so did acceptance (Crystal and colleagues, 2017). The Italian study found the same rise as conventional treatment became harder for the child.

In these surveys, the harder alternatives parents were asked to consider included sedation or general anaesthesia, and most parents in the 2017 study preferred SDF staining, even on front teeth, to those options. Our article on children who are scared of the dentist covers other ways to make visits easier.

Parents who have been through it are mostly satisfied

In the two studies that asked parents after their child had been treated, most were positive. In a Canadian study of 39 parents whose children were in an SDF trial, 94.9% said they would choose SDF again, with higher acceptance for back teeth (87.2%) than front teeth (69.2%) (Levesque and colleagues, Journal of Dentistry for Children, 2026).

A New York university clinic surveyed 79 parents after treatment and found that more than 90% were satisfied. Dissatisfaction was linked to three things: staining of front teeth, the tooth needing further treatment later, and a poorer understanding of the side effects beforehand. In the children followed up at that clinic, about half of the treated teeth later had a filling or were removed (Crystal and colleagues, Frontiers in Dental Medicine, 2023). A follow-up analysis of 30 parents' comments found that some parents had misunderstood how long the treatment would last and had not expected further treatment to be needed (Crystal and colleagues, Frontiers in Oral Health, 2024).

Children themselves seem less troubled than adults. The 2026 review found a median acceptance of SDF on back baby molars of 93.2% among children, again from studies of mixed quality.

Potassium iodide can lighten the stain, with a trade-off

Some silver fluoride products add a second liquid, potassium iodide, applied straight after. The evidence is mixed.

  • In a cluster randomised trial in children, groups that received potassium iodide had higher odds of avoiding black discolouration at 12 months. They also had lower caries arrest rates (65.4% and 51.2%, against 77.3% and 75.3% without it). The lead investigator was a paid consultant to the product maker (Turton and colleagues, Clinical and Experimental Dental Research, 2021).
  • A Brisbane trial in 12 adults with special needs (56 teeth) found that treated lesions had darkened by three months with both silver fluoride products tested, including one with potassium iodide (See and colleagues, JDR Clinical and Translational Research, 2025).
  • A 2026 trial of 46 baby teeth compared two potassium iodide strengths under a resin-modified glass ionomer filling and found that neither gave a consistent appearance benefit beyond the short term (Vaish and colleagues, European Archives of Paediatric Dentistry, 2026).

A 2021 systematic review described the evidence on potassium iodide and tooth colour as contradictory (Haiat and colleagues, PLoS One, 2021). It is reasonable to expect some darkening even when potassium iodide is used.

Covering the stain with a filling

Once decay has been stopped, a tooth-coloured filling can sometimes be placed over it. A 2026 review of nine laboratory studies found that composite resin masked SDF staining better than glass ionomer, but these were laboratory tests, not studies in patients (Mathur and colleagues, International Journal of Clinical Pediatric Dentistry, 2026). In a 12-month clinical trial in children aged 6 to 9 with deep decay in their first permanent molars, fillings placed over SDF had poorer colour and lustre than fillings placed without it (Baraka and colleagues, Journal of the American Dental Association, 2022).

On back baby teeth, another option is a preformed metal crown, which covers the tooth. Our article on stainless steel crowns for children explains when these are used.

Questions worth asking before treatment

  • Which teeth would be treated, and would the stain show when my child smiles?
  • What would the alternative involve for my child, and how many visits?
  • Is this an interim step, and what might the tooth need later?
  • How often will the tooth be checked or the liquid reapplied?
  • Can the area be covered with a filling later if the stain bothers us?

SDF at Lumi

Lumi offers SDF for suitable cases, such as early decay in young children. SDF stains the decayed area black, and whether it suits a particular tooth is decided at the examination. Our oral health therapists, Sabrina Tran and Jennifer Nguyen, see children and families and focus on prevention. You can read more about children's dentistry at Lumi and the Child Dental Benefits Schedule. Healthdirect's page on tooth decay is a useful general guide.

For dentists: show photographs and set expectations before consent

Showing parents clinical photographs of SDF-treated teeth, front and back, before they decide is a simple step consistent with this research. The New York City area acceptance study used photographs to draw out parents' views and found clear differences between front and back teeth (Crystal and colleagues, 2017), and parental dissatisfaction after treatment was linked to front tooth staining, later treatment and a poorer understanding of side effects (Crystal and colleagues, 2023). Explaining at the start that SDF is often an interim measure, and that further treatment may follow, may help with two of those three, and the authors of the follow-up qualitative study recommended preparing parents for likely further treatment when SDF is first proposed (Crystal and colleagues, 2024).

The limits: these are survey and qualitative studies, the 2023 study surveyed the parents of 79 of 209 treated children, with children with special healthcare needs over-represented, and we found no trial testing whether showing photographs changes satisfaction.

What parents ask about the stain

Does SDF stain healthy parts of the tooth?

The darkening is mainly in the decayed area. In the Brisbane trial of two silver fluoride products, colour change was significantly greater in treated lesions than in the neighbouring healthy tooth surface (See and colleagues, 2025).

Will the stain fade?

Expect it to last. The review of masking studies described SDF discolouration as irreversible, and the Brisbane researchers advised that patients be told the staining is long term. Covering it with a tooth-coloured filling is one option when appearance matters. On a baby tooth, the stain goes when the tooth is lost naturally.

Is a black spot a sign that treatment has failed?

Not by itself. Darkening is expected when SDF is used, and in the Brisbane trial lesions that responded to treatment showed larger colour changes. Whether the decay has stopped is judged at the review visit, which our article on SDF follow-up describes.

Making a booking

If your child has early decay and you would like to talk through SDF and the alternatives, you can book an appointment with our team in Melrose Park.

Sources

  • Crystal YO, Janal MN, Hamilton DS, Niederman R. Parental perceptions and acceptance of silver diamine fluoride staining. Journal of the American Dental Association, 2017. PubMed 28457477
  • Cappiello MC and colleagues. Parental perceptions and acceptance of silver diamine fluoride staining in Italy. International Journal of Paediatric Dentistry, 2025. PubMed 38853387
  • Cappiello MC and colleagues. Comparison of aesthetic perception and acceptability of SDF staining between Spanish and Italian parents. Scientific Reports, 2025. PubMed 39870784
  • Reinhard AG and colleagues. Acceptance of non-aesthetic caries treatment approaches in children: a systematic review. Acta Stomatologica Croatica, 2026. PubMed 42358910
  • Levesque J and colleagues. Parental acceptance of silver diammine fluoride for managing early childhood caries. Journal of Dentistry for Children, 2026. PubMed 42681737
  • Crystal YO, Jang JH, Janal MN, Raveis VH. Factors that influence parental satisfaction with SDF treatment. Frontiers in Dental Medicine, 2023. PubMed 39916926
  • Crystal YO, Jang JH, Raveis VH. Enhancing patient-provider encounters when proposing SDF therapy. Frontiers in Oral Health, 2024. PubMed 39364345
  • Turton B, Horn R, Durward C. Caries arrest and lesion appearance using two silver fluoride therapies with and without potassium iodide. Clinical and Experimental Dental Research, 2021. PubMed 33370847
  • See L and colleagues. Tooth discoloration from 2 silver fluorides used in adults with special needs. JDR Clinical and Translational Research, 2025. PubMed 38760973
  • Vaish P and colleagues. Saturated and 10% potassium iodide in reducing SDF staining under RMGIC restorations in primary teeth. European Archives of Paediatric Dentistry, 2026. PubMed 41942804
  • Haiat A and colleagues. SDF and potassium iodide: a systematic review. PLoS One, 2021. PubMed 34115788
  • Mathur A, Chaudhary Y, Shekhar S. Tooth-coloured restorative materials in masking SDF discoloration: a systematic review of in vitro studies. International Journal of Clinical Pediatric Dentistry, 2026. PubMed 41800005
  • Baraka M and colleagues. 38% SDF with or without potassium iodide in indirect pulp capping of young permanent molars. Journal of the American Dental Association, 2022. PubMed 36253166
  • healthdirect. Tooth decay. healthdirect.gov.au
Dr James Tran, dentist at Lumi Dental, Melrose Park

Written by Dr James Tran

Dr James Tran (BDent, University of Sydney; Graduate Diploma in Oral Implants) is a general dentist at Lumi Dental in Melrose Park. The team writes these articles to give clear, evidence-based dental information to help you make informed decisions about your care.

Inside Lumi Dental, Melrose Park

New patients

Your first visit is $149

A full 60 minute first visit with a check-up, clean, X-rays and a treatment plan. Usually $654, offer ends 31 December 2026. With most health funds there is no gap.

Open Monday to Saturday, and until 9:30pm on Thursdays. Free undercover parking at Melrose Central.