There are two kinds of yellow. One sits on the surface of the enamel as stain from coffee, tea, wine or smoking, and a professional clean removes much of it. The other comes from inside the tooth, where the naturally yellow dentine shows through the enamel, and that is the colour peroxide whitening is designed to lighten. Telling them apart is the first step, because it decides what will help: a clean, whitening gel, or something different.
Why teeth have a yellow tone at all
Enamel, the outer shell of a tooth, is translucent. Most of the colour you see comes from the dentine underneath, which is pale yellow to light brown. The thicker and more opaque the enamel, the whiter a tooth tends to look; the thinner and clearer it is, the more yellow shows through.
This also explains why teeth usually look yellower with age. Enamel gradually thins, and the tooth keeps laying down dentine on the inside, which is darker. Our article on why teeth look yellower as you get older explains that change. Teeth are also often a little yellower near the gums, where the enamel is thinnest.
On the tooth or in the tooth
Surface stain
Coffee, tea, red wine, curries and tobacco leave pigments that cling to the enamel, particularly near the gumline and between the teeth, where they often combine with tartar. The colour tends to be brownish yellow and patchy. A scale and clean by a dentist or OHT removes much of this, and some people find that is all they wanted. If the colour underneath is still yellow, whitening can follow. Our guide to whitening before or after a scale and clean explains the order.
Colour from the dentine
An even yellow across every tooth, present for years or since young adulthood, usually reflects the colour of the dentine and the thickness of the enamel. Genetics play a part, as does age. This is the kind of yellow that peroxide whitening tends to lighten well.
Colour that needs a different approach
Some discolouration behaves differently and is worth having assessed before whitening:
- Grey, brown or banded staining from tetracycline antibiotics taken while teeth were forming. It can lighten, but it usually needs much longer treatment. In one study, teeth with tetracycline staining were treated nightly with a 10% carbamide peroxide gel for six months (Leonard and colleagues, Journal of Esthetic and Restorative Dentistry, 2003).
- Fluorosis, which shows as white flecks or brown patches. Depending on the marks, whitening, microabrasion or resin infiltration may be considered.
- A single tooth darker than its neighbours, often after an old knock. The cause is often inside the tooth, so it needs an examination and usually an X-ray first.
- Thin or eroded enamel, where the yellow looks deeper and surfaces are smooth and glassy. Protecting the enamel comes first, and bonding may help more than whitening.

What peroxide gel does to yellow teeth
Professional whitening gels contain hydrogen peroxide, or carbamide peroxide, which breaks down into hydrogen peroxide. The peroxide moves through the enamel into the dentine and breaks down the pigment molecules that make teeth look yellow. It lightens the tooth without removing tooth structure. How much lighter teeth become varies from person to person and depends on the starting colour, the cause and how consistently the gel is used, so no one can promise a particular shade.
In Australia, the national Poisons Standard and state and territory laws allow tooth whitening products with more than 6% hydrogen peroxide, or more than 18% carbamide peroxide, to be sold, supplied and used only by registered dental practitioners, as the Australian Dental Association's policy statement sets out. Over-the-counter kits are limited to lower strengths.
Take-home whitening
Custom trays are made to fit your teeth and you wear a dentist-prescribed gel at home, either overnight or for a set time during the day, following the instructions for that gel. This gradual approach suits even, deep yellow from age or genetics. At Lumi, Lumi Home uses Boutique take-home whitening gels with custom trays, with an overnight gel for people with sensitive teeth and a daytime gel for those without sensitivity.
In-chair whitening followed by trays
A stronger gel applied in the chair gives a visible lift in one visit. In-chair whitening alone does not usually get yellow teeth all the way, partly because teeth dry out during the appointment and look lighter for a day or two afterwards. Take-home whitening is needed to continue and settle the result, which is why Lumi Refresh and Lumi Radiance both include Boutique take-home whitening. We explain this in why in-chair whitening alone will not get you all the way.
Temporary sensitivity during whitening is common and usually settles once treatment stops. A systematic review comparing at-home and in-office whitening (de Geus and colleagues, Operative Dentistry, 2016) found no significant difference between the two in the risk or intensity of sensitivity, or in how well they worked.
What whitening costs
As typical market ranges, not Lumi fees, dentist-supplied take-home whitening is about $300 to $700. Comparison site iSelect puts in-chair whitening at about $600 to $1,000 or more, and over-the-counter kits and strips at about $20 to $150. The teeth whitening cost guide goes into more detail.
Where whitening will not help
Peroxide only changes natural tooth structure. Fillings, bonding, crowns and veneers keep their colour, so they can look darker once the surrounding teeth lighten. If you have visible fillings at the front, read about whitening with fillings or bonding first. When colour cannot be reached by whitening, composite bonding or veneers can cover it, and many people whiten first so new work can be matched to the lighter shade.
Keeping yellow from coming back
As Lumi's usual guidance, whitening results typically last about 2 to 3 years before a top-up is needed to keep the same level, and habits make a big difference. Rinsing with water after coffee, tea or red wine helps, as does brushing twice a day with a fluoride toothpaste, cleaning between the teeth and keeping up regular cleans to remove surface stain. If your dentist recommends it, a small amount of top-up gel in your existing trays now and then can maintain the colour.
Questions we are often asked
Will whitening toothpaste fix yellow teeth?
It can remove some surface stain, but it does not contain enough peroxide, and is not in contact with the teeth for long enough, to change the colour of the dentine. Yellow that comes from inside the tooth rarely shifts much with toothpaste alone.
Can very yellow teeth still whiten?
Often yes. Yellow from the dentine generally responds well to peroxide gel, although the final result varies and cannot be guaranteed. An examination first checks the cause and rules out decay or gum problems.
Why do my teeth look more yellow near the gums?
Enamel is thinnest there, so more dentine shows through, and stain and tartar collect along the gumline. A clean removes the stain; whitening can lighten the colour underneath, though that area often stays slightly warmer in tone than the biting edges.
You can read how our options work on the teeth whitening page. Lumi offers a free consult for cosmetic treatment, including whitening; see current offers to book. After the consult you will usually receive a written treatment plan, often by email.
Sources
- Australian Dental Association. Policy statement 2.2.8: Teeth whitening (bleaching) by persons other than dental practitioners.
- de Geus JL, Wambier LM, Kossatz S, Loguercio AD, Reis A. At-home vs in-office bleaching: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Operative Dentistry, 2016.
- Leonard RH Jr, et al. Nightguard vital bleaching of tetracycline-stained teeth: 90 months post treatment. Journal of Esthetic and Restorative Dentistry, 2003.
- iSelect. Teeth whitening costs in Australia.









