Many people who spot a dark edge where an old crown meets the gum assume the tooth is rotting underneath. Usually it is not. On a crown that is ten or more years old, that line is most often the metal inside a porcelain-fused-to-metal crown starting to show, because the gum has drawn back a little. It is mainly a cosmetic problem, although a few signs mean it is worth having the tooth checked sooner rather than later.
Where the dark edge comes from
Porcelain-fused-to-metal crowns, often called PFM crowns, have a thin metal shell with tooth-coloured porcelain baked over it. For decades they were the standard choice because the metal gives strength and a precise fit. The weak point is cosmetic. At the very edge of the crown, where it meets the tooth, the porcelain is thin or absent and the metal collar can be close to the surface.
When the crown was first placed, that edge usually sat just under the gum and could not be seen. Over the years gums can recede, from hard brushing, gum disease, thin gum tissue, clenching or simply age, and the collar comes into view as a grey or black band. Recession around a crown does not mean the crown was poorly made. It often reveals an edge that was always going to show one day.
There are two related effects. Even before the metal edge is exposed, a thin gum can let the darker metal show through, giving the gum itself a greyish tint. And some older metal alloys can tarnish over time or leave a stain in the gum next to them, which deepens the colour further.
When the line suggests something else is going on
A thin, even line that has looked the same for years, on a tooth that feels fine, is usually only a cosmetic matter. A dark area is more likely to need attention if it comes with any of these:
- a gap you can catch with a fingernail or floss between the crown and the tooth
- a dark patch that is patchy or spreading, rather than a neat line along the edge
- tenderness when you bite, or sensitivity to cold or sweet
- swelling, bleeding or a pimple on the gum near the tooth
- a bad taste or smell that comes from that area
- a line that has appeared or darkened recently
These can be signs of decay starting at the crown edge, a leaking seal or gum infection. Decay under a crown can progress without much pain, so it is better found early with an examination and an X-ray.
Replacing the crown is usually the most reliable fix
If the tooth and gum around it are healthy, the dark line is usually dealt with by replacing the old crown with one made entirely of ceramic, such as zirconia or lithium disilicate. With no metal underneath, there is nothing dark to show if the gum moves again later. The dentist removes the old crown, checks the tooth for decay, reshapes the edge if needed and fits the new crown.
Sometimes a smaller step is possible. A crown that is still well sealed but has a small visible collar can occasionally be improved by adjusting the gum level or masking the edge, though the result is less predictable than a new crown. Where the recession itself is the main concern, a gum procedure may be discussed, and some patients are referred to a periodontist for this.
If decay or gum disease is found, that comes first. A new crown placed over an untreated problem will not last.
Why all-ceramic crowns rarely show this problem
Ceramic materials have improved greatly, and zirconia in particular is now strong enough for back teeth. For many visible teeth, an all-ceramic crown is now the usual choice, partly because it avoids the dark edge and partly because it lets light through more like a natural tooth. Gums can still recede around these crowns over time, but there is no metal to cast a shadow. We compare the main crown materials in our guide to zirconia vs porcelain-fused-to-metal crowns.
Other crown problems have different causes. Sensitivity in the first weeks after a new crown is covered in our article on whether a new crown should be sensitive to cold, and if a crown has come off completely, read what to do when a crown falls off.
Questions we are often asked
Is the black line harmful?
The line itself usually is not. It is a cosmetic sign of an older metal-based crown. It is still worth pointing it out at your next check-up so the dentist can confirm there is no decay or leak at the edge.
Is it decay or just the metal?
Metal usually shows as a smooth, even band that follows the gum. Decay tends to look patchier, may feel rough or soft and is often accompanied by sensitivity. You cannot reliably tell at home, and an examination with an X-ray is the way to be sure.
Will a new metal-free crown look perfect forever?
No crown lasts forever, and gums can keep changing with age. What a metal-free crown removes is this particular dark shadow. Good brushing at the gum line, cleaning between teeth and regular check-ups help the gum around any crown stay healthy for longer.
What does replacing it cost?
It depends on the tooth, the material and whether other work is needed first. A crown generally costs $1,500 to $2,500 in the Sydney market, as a typical range rather than a quote. An examination is the only way to get a figure for your tooth.
If a dark line at the gum bothers you, or you would like an older crown looked at, Lumi Dental offers a free cosmetic consult where we can talk through whether replacement is worth it for you. Book through our free cosmetic consult page, or see our current offers.









