For a single implant crown, zirconia and porcelain-fused-to-metal (PFM) both have good track records. In clinical studies, survival over the first few years is similar for both. The clearer differences are that solid zirconia crowns chip less often, and that zirconia avoids the metal that can sometimes show as a grey tinge at the gum line.
Two ways to build a crown
A PFM crown, also called metal-ceramic, has a thin metal framework underneath with tooth-coloured porcelain baked onto it. It has been used for decades and is still a common choice.
Zirconia (zirconium dioxide) is a dense, very strong ceramic. It is used in two main forms. A monolithic crown is milled from one solid block of zirconia, with no separate outer layer. A veneered or layered zirconia crown has a zirconia core with porcelain added on the outside for extra translucency, usually where looks matter most. Either kind of crown sits on an abutment that connects it to the implant, which our guide to the parts of a dental implant explains.
Survival is similar, chipping is not
A 2024 systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised trials in the Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry (Tajti and colleagues) compared monolithic zirconia with metal-ceramic single crowns on back-tooth implants. After about a year, there was no significant difference in bone levels around the implant, gum bleeding or implant failure. Crown survival was 97.5% for monolithic zirconia and 99.1% for metal-ceramic. The porcelain on metal-ceramic crowns, however, chipped in 7.6% of cases, compared with none of the monolithic zirconia crowns.
A larger 2021 review in Clinical Oral Implants Research (Pjetursson and colleagues) looked at all-ceramic implant crowns more broadly. Monolithic zirconia crowns had an estimated three-year survival of about 96%, similar to most other ceramics studied, and veneered (layered) crowns chipped significantly more often than monolithic ones.
Two points follow from this. Most of the chipping risk comes from a layer of porcelain on top of a stronger core, whether that core is metal or zirconia. And because the follow-up in these trials is short, neither material has a proven advantage over many years yet.
| Monolithic zirconia | Porcelain-fused-to-metal | |
|---|---|---|
| Structure | One solid ceramic piece | Metal framework with porcelain on top |
| Short-term survival in trials | High, similar to PFM | High, similar to zirconia |
| Chipping of the outer layer | Rare, as there is no separate layer | More common, as the porcelain can chip |
| Metal near the gum | None | Yes, which may show as a grey tinge if the gum is thin or recedes |
| Track record | Shorter, but growing | Several decades |
How each one looks
For front teeth, appearance usually drives the decision. Metal blocks light, so a PFM crown needs enough porcelain over the framework to look natural, and if the gum around it is thin or recedes over time, the metal edge can sometimes show as a darker line. Zirconia has no metal, which avoids this. Solid zirconia can look more opaque than natural enamel, so for a front tooth a layered zirconia or another ceramic may be chosen to match the neighbouring teeth more closely. For back teeth that are not easily seen, strength and resistance to chipping often matter more than translucency.
Factors that point one way or the other
The right material depends on the individual case. Things your dentist will weigh up include:
- where the implant is, and how visible the crown will be when you smile
- how thick your gum is around the implant
- how heavily you bite, including any clenching or teeth grinding
- how much space there is between the implant and the opposing teeth
- the condition and material of the teeth the crown will bite against
Whatever is chosen, the health of the gum and bone around the implant has a big effect on how long it lasts. Our guide to cleaning dental implants at home covers the daily habits that help.
Cost
As a typical Australian market range, not a Lumi fee, a single crown usually costs about $1,500 to $2,500, and a single implant with its crown about $4,000 to $7,000 in total. The material is only one part of the fee, alongside the abutment, lab work and the complexity of the case. Lumi has an in-house lab. For our pricing and current offers, see the dental implants page or our current deals.
Questions patients ask about implant crown materials
Can a zirconia crown still break?
It is uncommon, but no crown is unbreakable. Very heavy grinding can damage any material, and layered zirconia can chip in the same way as porcelain on metal. If an implant crown feels loose or the bite changes, see our advice on a loose implant crown.
Will either material stain?
Glazed ceramics resist staining well, although surface deposits can build up. Our article on whether implants stain or discolour goes into this.
Can the crown be changed later?
Often, yes. A crown can usually be replaced with a different material if needed, depending on how it is attached and the condition of the abutment and implant beneath it.
If you are planning an implant, or want to talk through crown materials for your own case, our dentists in Melrose Park offer a free implant consult; see current deals for details. You might also like to read how an implant joins the bone through osseointegration. This article is general information and not a substitute for personal dental advice.









