Nobody can tell you in advance exactly how many shades lighter your teeth will go, and a product that promises a fixed number is promising something it cannot know. In clinical trials, the change is usually a few steps on a dentist's shade guide. Where you personally end up depends mostly on how dark your teeth are to begin with and what kind of discolouration you have, rather than on the brand of gel.
To make sense of any number you are quoted, it helps to know what a "shade" is, why the steps are uneven, and which kinds of colour respond well.
A shade is one tab on a guide, not a fixed amount of colour
Dentists judge tooth colour by holding small porcelain tabs beside the teeth. The most widely used guide, the VITA classical, has 16 tabs. They fall into four families: A tabs have a reddish brown hue, B tabs reddish yellow, C tabs greyish and D tabs reddish grey. Within each family, a higher number is darker, so A3 is darker than A1.
To measure whitening, the tabs are lined up by value, meaning how light or dark they look regardless of hue. In that order the guide runs from B1, the lightest, through A1, B2, D2, A2, C1, C2, D4, A3, D3, B3, A3.5, B4, C3 and A4 to C4, the darkest. "Four shades lighter" normally means moving four places along that line. Our guide to tooth shade matching explains how the tabs are read in the chair.
The gaps between neighbouring tabs are not equal, so a move of one step in the darker part of the guide can look quite different from a move of one step near the light end. The count is shorthand rather than a precise measure.
What studies have measured
In a small trial of 20 people in Operative Dentistry (da Costa and colleagues, 2010), teeth whitened at home with 10% carbamide peroxide overnight for five nights changed by an average of three units on a bleaching shade guide, the same as teeth treated with one in-chair session of 25% hydrogen peroxide. Averages hide a wide spread, and some people move further while others move less.
Stronger gel does not automatically mean more steps. A 2025 network meta-analysis in the Japanese Dental Science Review (Cordeiro and colleagues), which pooled 13 randomised trials of take-home carbamide peroxide, found no significant difference in shade guide change between concentrations. Lower concentrations did, however, carry a lower risk of sensitivity, and 10% gel was linked with less sensitivity than 20 to 22% gel. Our article on carbamide and hydrogen peroxide explains how the two gels differ.
Starting colour sets how much room there is
Teeth that start around A3.5 have many tabs between them and the light end of the guide. Teeth that are already close to A1 or B1 have only one or two places left to move, so the step count stays small even when the teeth look clearly brighter. A small number is not a poor result if you started light.
Yellow responds well, grey is harder
Peroxide gels break down coloured molecules inside the tooth. Yellow and brown tones, which build up with age and with coffee, tea and red wine, tend to lighten readily. Surface stain from tea or smoking often lifts further once a professional clean has removed the outer layer. Grey or bluish tones, including the banding left by some antibiotics taken in childhood, usually respond more slowly and sometimes only partly, and bands may lighten unevenly. With white or brown spots from fluorosis, the surrounding enamel may lighten while the spots stay visible, and other treatments are sometimes combined. Our article on intrinsic and extrinsic staining explains these differences.
Enamel thickness matters too. Enamel is partly see-through, so much of a tooth's colour comes from the dentine underneath. Thinner enamel, which is more common with age and along the biting edges, can still look slightly translucent or grey after whitening.
Fillings, crowns and veneers stay the same colour
Porcelain and composite do not respond to whitening gel. If you have visible restorations at the front, they may look darker than your natural teeth once those lighten. They can be replaced to match after the new shade has settled, which is worth factoring in before you start.

Headline numbers on packaging are best read as upper limits
Many whitening products advertise "up to" a number of shades. Figures like these tend to reflect the best results under trial conditions, often from people who started with darker teeth, so a much smaller change can still be a normal outcome. Some brands use their own colour charts rather than a standard dental guide, so their "shades" may not line up with the steps a dentist records. Lighting, camera settings and whether the teeth were dried before a photo can all make a change look larger than it is.
How your shade is measured before and after
We record your starting shade before whitening, holding tabs against the upper front teeth in consistent light, and clinical photographs can be taken with a shade tab in the frame so the comparison is fair. Teeth lose a little water during bleaching, which makes them look lighter and slightly chalky at first. As they rehydrate over the following days, the colour settles back somewhat, so the final shade is best judged after a short wait rather than on the day you finish. How long it then holds depends largely on diet and habits, covered in how long teeth whitening lasts.
Natural teeth have a lighter limit
Once the dentine has lightened as far as it will go, extra bleaching tends to bring more sensitivity rather than more colour. Some shade guides include extra bleached shades lighter than B1 to describe results beyond the standard tabs. A very white shade can also look out of proportion with your skin tone and gums, so many people prefer a shade that suits their face over the lightest possible tab.
When whitening alone may not get you there
If your teeth have a grey tone, deep staining, or visible fillings or crowns at the front, it is worth having a shade assessment before buying any product. It may show that whitening is enough, or that it works best as a first step. A single darker tooth, a chipped edge or old fillings that no longer match can often be addressed with composite bonding once the new shade has settled. Where both shape and colour need to change, veneers may be an option, and our comparison of veneers and teeth whitening sets out the trade-offs.

What patients ask about shade change
Do in-chair treatments give more shades than trays?
Not necessarily. Systematic reviews comparing the two have found similar shade guide change overall. In-chair whitening shows a visible change sooner, trays work more gradually, and many people combine them so they can reach and then maintain a shade.
Why did my teeth darken slightly after I finished?
Bleaching temporarily dries the enamel, which makes teeth look lighter for a short time. As they rehydrate, the colour settles to its true result.
Can grey teeth be whitened?
Often they can be improved, but grey tones usually change more slowly and less predictably than yellow. A longer supervised course is sometimes used, and in some cases bonding or veneers give a more reliable result.
See how far your own teeth might move
We can record your starting shade, look at the type of discolouration you have and talk through options at our Melrose Park practice, without promising a particular shade. Book a complimentary cosmetic consult, or read about Lumi Home, Lumi Refresh and Lumi Radiance on the teeth whitening page.
Sources
- Dentalcare.com: Shade selection using the VITA classical shade guide
- da Costa JB et al. Comparison of at-home and in-office tooth whitening using a novel shade guide. Operative Dentistry, 2010
- Cordeiro DCF et al. What is the optimal concentration of carbamide peroxide for at-home bleaching? A systematic review and network meta-analysis. Japanese Dental Science Review, 2025
- de Geus JL et al. At-home vs in-office bleaching: an updated systematic review and meta-analysis. Operative Dentistry, 2025









