Book Online

All health funds accepted · Payment plans available, humm from $0 deposit · CDBS bulk billing

All health funds accepted · Payment plans available, humm from $0 deposit · CDBS bulk billing

Book online

Consult room at Lumi Dental with a desk, chairs and timber cabinetry

THE LUMI BLOG

Short dental implants vs sinus lift: options for the upper back jaw

When bone under the upper back teeth is thin, a short implant or a sinus lift with a longer implant may be options, and trials report similar survival for both in the first years.

Dr James Tran, dentist at Lumi Dental Melrose Park

Dr James Tran

October 4, 2026 · Implants · 6 min read

Being told you need a sinus lift before an upper back implant can sound like a big extra step, and sometimes it is unavoidable. For many people with a moderate amount of bone, though, a shorter implant that fits the bone already there is a reasonable alternative. Randomised trials comparing the two have found similar implant survival in the first few years, so the choice usually comes down to how much bone your scan shows and how much surgery and waiting you are prepared for.

Bone under the upper back teeth tends to run out

The roots of the upper premolars and molars sit just beneath the maxillary sinus, an air space inside the cheekbone. After those teeth are lost, the bone that held them starts to shrink, and the floor of the sinus can drop down into the space the roots once filled. The squeeze from both directions can leave only a few millimetres of bone between the gum and the sinus.

The bone here is also naturally softer than in the lower jaw. A standard-length implant may simply not fit without pushing into the sinus, which is why this part of the mouth needs careful measuring before anything is decided.

Measuring the bone comes first

A 3D scan of the jaw (CBCT) shows the height and width of bone beneath the sinus, the shape of the sinus floor and how dense the bone looks. From those measurements a dentist can work out whether a short implant will fit, whether a small lift from below is enough, or whether a larger graft is needed. Our explainer on the 3D CBCT scan covers what the scan involves.

A patient having a 3D dental X-ray at Lumi Dental
A 3D scan shows how much bone sits under the sinus before any implant is planned.

As a rough guide, the less bone height there is, the more likely a graft becomes. The more there is, the more likely a short implant can be used on its own. General health, smoking, gum health, any history of sinus problems and how many teeth are being replaced also feed into the plan.

A short implant works with the bone you have

Short implants are usually defined as 8 mm long or less, with some reviews looking at implants of 6 mm or shorter. Rather than building bone up to suit a longer implant, the implant is chosen to suit the bone that is already present. Better surface treatments and thread designs have helped shorter implants bond well with bone.

The main appeal is that there is no graft. That usually means a single surgery, less swelling and a shorter overall wait before the new tooth goes in. Short implants are not right for everyone. There still has to be a minimum height of reasonable bone, and the dentist will think about your bite, the size of the crown that will sit on top, and any clenching or grinding.

A sinus lift adds bone so a longer implant fits

A sinus lift, also called sinus augmentation, gently raises the thin membrane lining the sinus floor and places bone graft material underneath. Once the graft has matured, there is room for a longer implant. There are two main ways of doing it.

Lifting from below

When only a little extra height is needed, the sinus floor can be gently pushed up through the same opening that will hold the implant. This is often called a crestal or osteotome lift. It is less invasive, and the implant can sometimes be placed at the same visit.

Lifting through a side window

For a bigger gain in height, a small window is made in the side wall of the sinus, through the gum above the missing tooth. The membrane is lifted and graft material packed into the space. This approach can create much more bone, but it is the larger procedure of the two.

Either way, a graft generally means waiting several months for it to mature before the final tooth is fitted, and sometimes a second surgery to place the implant. Possible problems include a tear in the sinus membrane, swelling, bruising, a blocked or congested feeling in the sinus and, less often, infection of the graft. Our guide to bone grafts and sinus lifts explains the graft materials in more detail.

What trials comparing the two have found

Several systematic reviews have pooled randomised trials that compared short implants with longer implants placed after a sinus lift. Their findings are broadly consistent on survival:

  • Fan and colleagues (Clinical Implant Dentistry and Related Research, 2017) combined seven trials and found no difference in survival. The short implant groups had fewer complications overall.
  • Yan and colleagues (BMJ Open, 2019) looked at implants of 6 mm or less and found comparable survival over 1 to 3 years of follow-up and beyond, with less bone loss around the implant and fewer reactions after surgery.
  • Wang and colleagues (Journal of Stomatology, Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, 2026) pooled eight trials and again found no significant difference in failure rates, with slightly less bone loss around short implants.

Findings on crown-related problems such as screw loosening have been mixed. One review (Lozano-Carrascal and colleagues, Medicina Oral, Patología Oral y Cirugía Bucal, 2020) found no significant difference in prosthetic complications, but it did find more biological complications around short implants, so the picture is not one-sided. Most of the trials follow patients for a few years rather than decades, and results depend on choosing the right patients and careful technique.

ConsiderationShort implantSinus lift with longer implant
Bone neededEnough height for an implant of about 8 mm or lessCan work with very little bone because height is added
Number of surgeriesUsually one, with no graftGraft plus implant, sometimes in two stages
Waiting timeTime for the implant to bond with boneExtra months for the graft to mature
Main risksNeeds careful bite planning on a shorter implantMembrane tear, swelling, sinus congestion, graft infection
Who it may suitModerate bone loss, people wanting less surgery or a shorter waitSevere bone loss, or where a longer implant is preferred

When bone is extremely limited right across the upper jaw, some people are assessed for other approaches, such as zygomatic implants that anchor into the cheekbone. These are reserved for particular cases.

How the choice affects cost

The graft is the main cost difference. A sinus lift is an extra procedure on top of the implant and crown, with its own materials and appointments, while a short implant avoids it. As a typical market range rather than Lumi's fee, a single implant with a crown in Sydney is usually around $4,000 to $7,000 before any grafting. Our dental implant cost guide goes through the fees in more detail, and you will usually receive a written treatment plan with costs, often by email, after your assessment.

Treatment room at Lumi Dental with a 3D scan of the teeth on the screen
Implant options are planned around the bone shown on your scan.

Questions about short implants and sinus lifts

Do short implants last as long as longer ones?

Trials have found similar survival for short implants and longer implants placed after a sinus lift over the first few years. Long-term data beyond that is more limited, so careful planning of the bite and the crown matters.

Does a sinus lift hurt?

It is done under local anaesthetic, so the procedure itself should not be painful. Swelling, bruising and some pressure in the sinus are common for a few days afterwards and can usually be managed with standard pain relief. Ask us about sedation options if you feel anxious about surgery.

Can I avoid a sinus lift altogether?

Many people with moderate bone loss can, by using a short implant. If the bone is very thin, a lift or another approach may still be needed, and the 3D scan is what confirms it. If the tooth you are replacing is a molar, our article on replacing a back molar with an implant covers other points to consider.

Talk through your upper jaw options

If you have lost an upper back tooth and been told you might need a sinus lift, it helps to understand every option before deciding. At Lumi Dental in Melrose Park we can take a 3D scan, explain if a short implant or a sinus lift may suit you, and set out the plan in writing. Read more about dental implants at Lumi, ask about a free implant consult through our contact page, and see current deals for any offers.

This article is general information only and is not a substitute for personalised advice from a registered dental practitioner.

Dr James Tran, dentist at Lumi Dental, Melrose Park

Written by Dr James Tran

Dr James Tran (BDent, University of Sydney; Graduate Diploma in Oral Implants) is a general dentist at Lumi Dental in Melrose Park. The team writes these articles to give clear, evidence-based dental information to help you make informed decisions about your care.

Inside Lumi Dental, Melrose Park

New patients

Your first visit is $149

A full 60 minute first visit with a check-up, clean, X-rays and a treatment plan. Usually $654, offer ends 31 December 2026. With most health funds there is no gap.

Open Monday to Saturday, and until 9:30pm on Thursdays. Free undercover parking at Melrose Central.