Both gold and monolithic zirconia are used for crowns on molars. What may surprise you is that we did not find a clinical trial comparing how long a gold crown and a zirconia crown last. The decision rests on two separate bodies of evidence: decades of data on cast gold, and a shorter but growing record for zirconia.
This article sets out what each body of evidence shows, where the gaps are, and the practical points that may matter for a particular tooth.
The closest head to head trials used older ceramics, not zirconia
The longest comparisons involving gold come from German university studies of cast gold partial crowns, which cover part of the tooth, including some of the cusps, rather than the whole tooth.
In a randomised split-mouth trial from Regensburg, 29 patients each received one cast gold partial crown and one milled ceramic partial crown. At 5.5 years, estimated survival was 93.3% for gold and 88.8% for ceramic, and the difference was not statistically significant (Federlin and colleagues, American Journal of Dentistry, 2010). The same trial was reported again at 20 years. Estimated survival was 69% for gold and 53% for ceramic, again without a significant difference, but by then only 11 patients could be examined. Among those, gold scored better for marginal adaptation and surface staining (Cieplik and colleagues, Dental Materials, 2025).
A retrospective study from Würzburg followed ceramic inlays and onlays and cast gold partial crowns placed by supervised dental students, for up to 24.8 years. Survival was about 92% for both ceramic and gold at 23.5 years. The main problem differed by material: ceramic fracture was the most common complication with ceramic (6.7%), while problems with the nerve of the tooth were most common under gold (8.8%) (Krug and colleagues, Clinical Oral Investigations, 2024).
The ceramics in these studies were a feldspathic ceramic and a leucite reinforced glass ceramic, not zirconia. In the 2026 review described below, feldspathic and silica-based ceramic crowns had the lowest five-year survival of the materials pooled (90.4%). These trials show that gold can perform well over very long periods. They do not tell us how gold compares with zirconia.
Gold has records stretching over decades
A US study of 1,314 cast gold inlays, onlays and crowns in 114 patients, all placed by one dentist, found that 95.4% had not needed replacing. Of these restorations, 72% had been in service for more than 20 years and some for over 40 (Donovan and colleagues, Journal of Esthetic and Restorative Dentistry, 2004). All were cemented with zinc phosphate cement. Results from a single practitioner may not apply everywhere.
Monolithic zirconia has strong five-year results
Monolithic means the crown is made from a single block of zirconia with no layer of porcelain on top. A 2026 systematic review pooled 64 clinical studies of single crowns on natural teeth. Estimated five-year survival was 96.8% for monolithic zirconia and 97.1% for porcelain fused to metal. Monolithic zirconia and monolithic lithium disilicate crowns had significantly fewer ceramic fractures and chips than layered versions (Pjetursson and colleagues, International Journal of Prosthodontics, 2026).
Five years is a useful result, but it is a fraction of the follow-up that exists for gold. An earlier review of monolithic zirconia crowns found studies with follow-up of only 0.3 to 2.1 years and high variation between them (Leitão and colleagues, Journal of Prosthodontic Research, 2022). Our article on zirconia types and their strength explains why the grade of zirconia matters for a back tooth.
What the evidence says for people who grind
A randomised trial in Heidelberg assessed 109 patients for sleep bruxism with a questionnaire, an examination and a portable muscle activity recorder, then randomly allocated monolithic zirconia or lithium disilicate molar crowns. Night guards were not allowed. Over three years there were no technical complications in any group, and survival of zirconia crowns was similar with and without bruxism: 95.2% and 95.8%. Success rates for zirconia were lower in people with bruxism (85.7% against 95.8%), but the difference was not statistically significant (Bömicke and colleagues, Journal of Dentistry, 2026).
The groups were small, about 21 to 27 people each, and three years is short. There was no gold group, so the trial cannot say whether gold would have done better or worse, and we found no trial of gold crowns in people who grind. Healthdirect's page on teeth grinding covers causes and management, and our guide to night guards for grinding covers guards for people who grind.
Wear on the opposite tooth: mostly laboratory data
One question with any crown is how much it wears the tooth it bites against, and how much it wears itself. For gold and zirconia, the direct comparisons come from the laboratory.
- In a Korean wear test, enamel rubbed against zirconia lost 0.47 cubic millimetres, while gold crowns and zirconia crowns each lost about 0.01. The authors suggested zirconia crowns are not recommended for heavy grinders, a conclusion drawn from a laboratory test (Kwon and colleagues, Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials, 2015).
- A Japanese study tested zirconia, lithium disilicate, gold and enamel against enamel. Polished zirconia and gold caused less wear on the opposing enamel than ground surfaces in one test set, and in another set zirconia and lithium disilicate wore enamel more than enamel did (Tachibana and colleagues, Dental Materials Journal, 2021).
- When crowns made of three dental alloys were run against zirconia in a chewing simulator, rough zirconia wore the alloys significantly more than smooth zirconia did, and gold alloy against rough zirconia showed the most wear of all the groups tested (Cha and colleagues, Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry, 2020).
The common thread is that surface finish matters. Our article on zirconia crowns and wear on the opposite tooth covers the clinical studies on zirconia in more detail.
How they compare in practice
| Point | Gold | Monolithic zirconia |
|---|---|---|
| Look | Metal coloured | Tooth coloured |
| Longest clinical follow-up | Decades, mostly older cohorts and partial crowns | Pooled data to about five years |
| Trial comparing how long each lasts | None found | None found |
| Grinding | Long record, no trial in grinders found | One three-year randomised trial: no technical complications, and no significant difference with or without grinding |
| Wear on opposing teeth | Limited lab data: less enamel wear when polished than when ground in one test | Lab data: less enamel wear when polished than when ground, but more than enamel in one test |
Other points can matter for one person and not another. Some people would rather not show metal when they laugh, even on a second molar. Some are concerned about metal allergy, which is covered in our article on gold allergy and dental gold. If you expect regular MRI scans of the head, our article on crowns, braces and fillings in an MRI scan sets out what studies found for different materials. For the case for gold more broadly, see gold crowns and gold onlays.
As a typical Australian market range, a crown commonly costs $1,500 to $2,500. These are general market figures, not Lumi fees, and the quote for a particular tooth depends on the material and the work involved.

For dentists: polish zirconia after every occlusal adjustment
When a monolithic zirconia crown is adjusted chairside, finishing it back to a polished surface before it leaves the room is a practical habit with laboratory support. In Tachibana and colleagues (2021), polished zirconia caused less antagonist enamel wear than ground zirconia in two of three test set-ups, and Cha and colleagues (2020) found that rough zirconia wore opposing gold alloy more than smooth zirconia. The Cha findings are most relevant when the opposing tooth carries an existing gold restoration.
The limits are real: both studies are in vitro and use machines rather than real chewing, and neither tells you how much polish is enough in the mouth. In the third Tachibana set-up, zirconia wore enamel more than enamel did regardless of surface roughness, so polishing may reduce but not remove the difference. We found no clinical study comparing antagonist wear on gold against zirconia crowns directly.
Questions about gold and zirconia
Is gold stronger than zirconia?
They are different kinds of material: gold is a metal alloy and zirconia is a ceramic. Both have clinical records in the studies above, much longer for gold, and we did not find a clinical trial comparing how long each lasts.
I already have a gold crown. Should it be replaced with zirconia?
Not just because a newer material exists. If a gold crown fits well and causes no problems, the long-term data on gold suggest it may keep working for many years. Whether any crown needs replacing is a decision for your dentist after examining it.
Does Lumi offer zirconia crowns?
Yes. Zirconia is one of the crown materials Lumi offers, alongside e.max (lithium disilicate), and the material for a particular tooth can be discussed with your dentist. Our page on crowns and bridges explains the process.
Talking through the options
If a back tooth needs a crown, the material is worth discussing before the tooth is prepared. After your examination at Lumi in Melrose Park you will usually receive a written treatment plan, often by email, setting out the options for that tooth. You can book an appointment online.
Sources
- Federlin M, Hiller KA, Schmalz G. Controlled, prospective clinical split-mouth study of cast gold vs. ceramic partial crowns: 5.5 year results. American Journal of Dentistry, 2010. PubMed 20718214
- Cieplik F and colleagues. Gold vs. CAD/CAM ceramic partial-crowns: 20-year randomized clinical study. Dental Materials, 2025. DOI
- Krug R and colleagues. Long-term performance of ceramic in/-onlays vs. cast gold partial crowns. Clinical Oral Investigations, 2024. PubMed 38702521
- Donovan T and colleagues. Retrospective clinical evaluation of 1,314 cast gold restorations in service from 1 to 52 years. Journal of Esthetic and Restorative Dentistry, 2004. PubMed 15597641
- Pjetursson BE and colleagues. Survival, failure and complication rates of metal-ceramic, veneered and monolithic all-ceramic tooth-supported single crowns, part 1. International Journal of Prosthodontics, 2026. PubMed 41489982
- Leitão CIMB and colleagues. Clinical performance of monolithic CAD/CAM tooth-supported zirconia restorations. Journal of Prosthodontic Research, 2022. PubMed 34615842
- Bömicke W and colleagues. Ceramic crowns and sleep bruxism: 3-year results of a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Dentistry, 2026. PubMed 41967567
- Kwon MS, Oh SY, Cho SA. Two-body wear comparison of zirconia crown, gold crown, and enamel against zirconia. Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials, 2015. PubMed 25837341
- Tachibana K and colleagues. The need for polishing and occlusal adjustment of zirconia prostheses for wear on antagonist teeth. Dental Materials Journal, 2021. PubMed 33456027
- Cha MS and colleagues. A comparative study of the wear of dental alloys against monolithic zirconia. Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry, 2020. PubMed 31653400
- healthdirect. Teeth grinding. healthdirect.gov.au









