Book Online

All health funds accepted · Payment plans available, humm from $0 deposit · CDBS bulk billing

All health funds accepted · Payment plans available, humm from $0 deposit · CDBS bulk billing

Book online

A treatment room at Lumi Dental with the dental chair ready for a patient

THE LUMI BLOG

Inlays, onlays, crowns and fillings: which restoration is right for your tooth?

How a dentist chooses between a filling, inlay, onlay or crown for a damaged back tooth, what research shows about how long each lasts, and what each involves.

Dr James Tran, dentist at Lumi Dental Melrose Park

Dr James Tran

May 24, 2026 · Patient Education · 9 min read

A larger restoration is not automatically a stronger one. Each step from a filling to an inlay, an onlay and then a crown removes more of your natural tooth, and natural tooth is still the best material available. The right choice is the smallest restoration that will reliably hold up under your bite, and that depends mostly on how much sound tooth is left and where the damage sits.

This guide explains how a dentist weighs those four options for a back tooth, what the research says about how long each tends to last, and what each one involves in time and cost.

How much sound tooth remains decides the choice

Modern restorative dentistry follows a minimally invasive approach: remove the decay or failed material, keep as much healthy enamel and dentine as possible, and only cover more of the tooth when the remaining walls genuinely need protection. Picture the options as a ladder.

  • Filling: placed directly into the cavity in one visit. Removes the least tooth.
  • Inlay: made outside the mouth and bonded into the cavity, sitting within the cusps (the raised corners of a back tooth).
  • Onlay: also made outside the mouth, but extends over one or more cusps to protect them.
  • Crown: covers the whole visible tooth. Removes the most structure, because every wall is shaped to make room for it.

Choosing a rung too low can mean the restoration or the tooth breaks early. Choosing one too high costs tooth structure that never needed to go. The examination and X-rays are what show where your tooth sits.

Fillings suit most cavities

For small and moderate cavities with strong walls around them, a tooth-coloured composite filling is usually the right answer. The material goes in soft, is shaped and hardened with a curing light, and is polished at the same appointment. It is quicker, cheaper and more conservative than any lab-made option.

Size matters, though. A large systematic review of posterior composite fillings by Opdam and colleagues (Journal of Dental Research, 2014) found that the risk of failure rose with the number of tooth surfaces restored, and was also higher in people at high risk of decay. The main reasons fillings failed were new decay and fracture. A small filling on a back tooth can serve for many years. A filling that replaces most of the chewing surface and several walls is under much more strain.

So if your dentist suggests a filling for a modest cavity, that is usually the sensible choice, and money saved can go toward prevention such as regular cleans and fluoride.

A dentist in a mask and gloves treating a young patient lying back in the dental chair
Most cavities found at a check-up can be restored with a filling in a single visit.

An inlay rebuilds the centre of a back tooth

An inlay fills a cavity that sits between the cusps. Because it is made from ceramic, composite or gold outside the mouth and then bonded or cemented in, it is fully hardened before it goes in and can be shaped very precisely against the neighbouring tooth. A good contact point matters: it stops food packing between teeth and makes flossing easier.

Inlays are worth considering when a cavity is too wide for a filling to be confident about, but the cusps around it are still thick and sound. That situation often arises when an old amalgam filling is removed and the space underneath turns out to be larger than it looked. The trade-offs are a second appointment, a higher fee and a little extra shaping so the inlay can slide into place.

An onlay protects a weakened cusp

When a cusp is cracked, undermined by decay or left thin by a large old filling, it is at risk of snapping off. An onlay replaces the missing structure and caps the weak cusp, while leaving the strong parts of the tooth alone. A crown would solve the same problem, but only by reducing every wall, including the healthy ones.

Ceramic onlays have a good track record. In a systematic review by Morimoto and colleagues (Journal of Dental Research, 2016), glass-ceramic and porcelain inlays, onlays and overlays had estimated survival rates of 92 to 95 per cent at five years and 91 per cent at ten years. Fracture or chipping was the most common reason they failed, which is one reason heavy grinding is taken into account when planning one.

A crown suits teeth whose walls are failing

A crown is the right choice when the outer walls themselves are the problem: several cusps lost, a crack running down a wall, or so little tooth left that there is not enough enamel to bond an onlay to. Covering the whole tooth holds it together under biting forces.

Crowns made from modern materials perform well. A systematic review by Sailer and colleagues (Dental Materials, 2015) estimated five-year survival of about 95 per cent for metal-ceramic crowns and about 97 per cent for lithium disilicate or leucite glass-ceramic crowns. The cost is the amount of tooth removed, which is why dentists generally avoid a crown when an onlay would protect the tooth just as well. You can read more on crowns and bridges at Lumi.

Root-filled back teeth usually need their cusps covered

A back tooth that has had root canal treatment has usually lost a lot of internal structure, and it is more prone to splitting. A well-known study by Aquilino and Caplan (Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry, 2002) found that root-filled teeth without a crown were lost at about six times the rate of those that were crowned. That study was observational, from a single university clinic, so it shows a strong association rather than proof.

A crown is no longer the only way to provide that protection. A 2024 systematic review by Alhamdan and colleagues (Cureus) found that bonded partial ceramic restorations, such as onlays, had survival comparable to full crowns on root-filled posterior teeth, while noting that the number of studies is still limited. For a root-filled tooth with thick walls left, an onlay can be a reasonable option. For a tooth with thin walls, a crown is usually safer.

When an onlay and a crown are both reasonable

Some teeth sit in between. In those cases the dentist weighs:

  • how much thick enamel remains around the edge of the cavity, since bonding depends on it
  • how heavy the bite is on that tooth
  • any clenching or grinding, especially at night
  • whether there is a crack, and how far it seems to extend
  • how visible the tooth is when you smile

If both options are offered, a fair question is which one keeps more of your own tooth, and what the risks of each are for your bite. Where an onlay is chosen for someone who grinds, a night guard is often suggested to protect it.

A quick word on materials

Ceramics such as lithium disilicate are tooth-coloured, strong and bond well to enamel, so they are widely used for inlays, onlays and crowns. Composite can also be used for indirect inlays and onlays and is easier to repair if it chips. Zirconia is very strong and is often chosen for crowns on heavily loaded back teeth. Gold has the longest history of all, but few people now choose its colour. Your dentist will suggest a material based on the tooth, your bite and how visible it is.

What each option involves

A filling is a single appointment. The tooth is numbed, the decay removed, and the composite built up and polished. You can usually eat on it once the numbness wears off.

Inlays, onlays and lab-made crowns usually take two appointments. At the first, the tooth is prepared and a scan or impression is taken, and a temporary restoration is placed. The restoration is then made to fit that model. At the second visit the temporary is removed and the final piece is checked for fit, colour and bite before it is bonded or cemented.

Lumi Dental treatment room with a 3D digital scan of a patient's teeth on the monitor
A digital scan records the prepared tooth so the restoration can be made to fit it.

At Lumi we have a 3D intraoral scanner and an in-house lab, so the digital record of your tooth can go straight to the people making the restoration.

Typical costs

Fees vary with the size of the restoration, the material and the practice. As a general guide, the Australian Dental Association's 2022 fee survey, as reported by CHOICE, found the average fee for a one-surface filling on a back tooth was $178 (most fees between $135 and $248), and $220 for a two-surface filling (most between $171 and $305). Larger fillings cost more. A crown typically sits around $1,500 to $2,500 in the general market.

Inlays and onlays involve laboratory work and a second visit, so they cost considerably more than a filling, and an onlay is often closer to a crown in price. These are typical market figures, not Lumi fees. For our current pricing, see our current offers, and our guides to filling costs and crown costs go into more detail.

Comparing quotes is easiest with item numbers, because every health fund uses the same Australian schedule of dental services to calculate rebates.

Small problems cost less to fix

Decay that is left alone tends to spread through the softer dentine underneath the enamel. A cavity that could have taken a filling may later need an onlay or crown, and if decay reaches the nerve, root canal treatment as well. Typical market ranges for root canal treatment are about $1,000 for a front tooth to $3,000 for a molar, before the crown. If the tooth cannot be saved, a single implant with its crown typically costs $4,000 to $7,000.

None of this is a reason for alarm. It is the case for regular check-ups, which find cavities while they are still small. Our guide to how cavities start and how to prevent them covers the habits that make the biggest difference.

What patients ask about inlays and onlays

Will my health fund cover an inlay or onlay?

Many extras policies with major dental cover pay a benefit toward inlays, onlays and crowns, but the amount depends entirely on your policy and remaining limits. Ask for the item numbers and check with your fund before treatment.

Can a crown or onlay be whitened later?

No. Whitening lightens natural enamel, but ceramic and composite restorations keep the colour they were made in. If you are thinking about whitening, it is best done before a visible restoration is made, so the new piece can be matched to your lighter shade.

Can an old filling be replaced with an onlay?

Yes, this is one of the most common reasons for an onlay. When a large old filling cracks or develops decay underneath, the dentist removes it, looks at what is left and chooses the restoration that suits the remaining tooth.

Is a crown better than an onlay for cosmetic reasons?

Not on a back tooth that only needs a cusp protected. Ceramic onlays are tooth-coloured and blend well. Choosing a crown purely for appearance means losing tooth structure for little benefit. For front teeth, the comparison between crowns and veneers is usually the more relevant one.

Getting a second look at your options

At Lumi Dental in Melrose Park, Dr James Tran and our team start from the same principle: restore the tooth with the least invasive option that will hold up for you. If you have been told you need a crown and would like to know whether an onlay could work instead, or you simply want a sore back tooth checked, book an examination and we will talk you through what the X-rays and examination show.

Dr James Tran, dentist at Lumi Dental, Melrose Park

Written by Dr James Tran

Dr James Tran (BDent, University of Sydney; Graduate Diploma in Oral Implants) is a general dentist at Lumi Dental in Melrose Park. The team writes these articles to give clear, evidence-based dental information to help you make informed decisions about your care.

Inside Lumi Dental, Melrose Park

New patients

Your first visit is $149

A full 60 minute first visit with a check-up, clean, X-rays and a treatment plan. Usually $654, offer ends 31 December 2026. With most health funds there is no gap.

Open Monday to Saturday, and until 9:30pm on Thursdays. Free undercover parking at Melrose Central.