An onlay that has come off in one piece can often be bonded back on, but not in the same way a loose crown is usually re-cemented. Most onlays rely more on a resin bond to enamel and dentine than on the shape of the tooth to stay in place, so both the onlay and the tooth need to be cleaned and treated again before that bond can be rebuilt. Whether the original onlay is reused depends on what the dentist finds when the tooth and the onlay are examined.
This article covers what to do in the first few hours, why onlays sometimes let go, and what the research says about rebonding the same piece. If it was a full crown that came off, our article on what to do when a crown falls off is the better guide.
Keep the onlay and protect the tooth
Rinse the onlay under lukewarm water, dry it gently and put it in a small clean container. Do not try to clean the inside with a brush or soak it in anything. The fitting surface is the part that has to be prepared again for bonding, and it is worth leaving that work to the dentist.
The tooth underneath will feel rough or sharp to the tongue and may be sensitive to cold or sweet food. Chew on the other side, avoid hard and sticky food, and keep brushing the area gently with a soft brush and fluoride toothpaste. Household glue is not made for use in the mouth and should not be used to hold the onlay in place.
Call the practice and say that an onlay (or a partial crown, inlay or overlay) has come off, rather than a filling, so enough time can be booked. Lumi offers emergency appointments.
If the tooth becomes painful or the gum around it swells, healthdirect advises emergency medical care for swelling around the eye or neck or for trouble breathing or speaking, and seeing a dentist for a fever over 38°C or trouble swallowing (healthdirect, toothache and gum swelling).
Fracture, not debonding, is the most common reason onlays fail
In clinical studies, most ceramic onlays were still in place years after they were fitted. A meta-analysis of 14 clinical studies of ceramic inlays, onlays and overlays, each with more than five years of follow-up, estimated survival of 92% to 95% at five years and 91% at ten years. Among the failures, fractures or chipping were recorded in 4%, endodontic problems in 3%, decay in 1% and debonding in 1% (Morimoto and colleagues, Journal of Dental Research, 2016).
A systematic review of ceramic onlays by researchers at the University of Melbourne also found that fracture was the most common reason for failure, but in that review debonding came second, ahead of decay. Onlays on teeth without a living nerve (usually root-filled teeth), teeth further back in the mouth and teeth in people with clenching or grinding habits appeared more likely to fail (Abduo and Sambrook, Journal of Esthetic and Restorative Dentistry, 2018).
The bonding method used at the fitting may matter
Because an onlay depends on its bond, the way it was fitted may affect how likely it is to come off. In a randomised split-mouth trial at the University of Regensburg, 50 people each received three machined ceramic partial crowns. Of the 31 people examined at 39 months, survival was 96% and 88% for the two groups fitted with a universal adhesive and resin cement, compared with 69% for those fitted with a self-adhesive resin cement alone, and the failures recorded included debonding and fractures (Scholz and colleagues, Journal of Dentistry, 2021). A meta-analysis of nine randomised trials also found self-adhesive cements performed worse than self-etch and selective-etch protocols for debonding and survival, although they did not differ significantly from total-etch protocols over the relatively short follow-up available (Alghauli and colleagues, Journal of Dentistry, 2023).
Our article on bonded and cemented crowns explains these cement types in more detail.
What the dentist checks before rebonding
The decision rests on three things. The first is the onlay itself: if it is cracked or chipped, a new one is usually needed. The second is the tooth: the dentist looks for decay, a broken cusp or a crack, any of which may need treating first and can change the shape the onlay has to fit. The third is the fit: an intact onlay is tried back on to confirm it still sits fully down and the bite is right.
If the tooth has a root filling, has had a lot of tooth lost, or has a history of grinding, this can also be a good time to talk about whether an onlay is still the right choice. Our article on onlays and crowns after root canal treatment covers that question.
Laboratory studies suggest a cleaned onlay can bond again
Much of the evidence on rebonding comes from laboratory tests rather than patients, so it shows what is possible on test samples, not how long a rebonded onlay will last in the mouth.
In one study of lithium disilicate ceramic samples, specimens that had been bonded, debonded and then cleaned with a heat-based laboratory protocol bonded again with a shear bond strength similar to that of freshly bonded samples, with no significant difference between the groups (Pineda-Vásquez and colleagues, Journal of Clinical and Experimental Dentistry, 2019). In a second study of debonded lithium disilicate discs, treating the surface with a laser before rebonding gave the lowest bond strength of the groups tested and did not improve bonding compared with conventional hydrofluoric acid and silane treatment, although the laser-treated samples had higher compressive strength (Albaker and colleagues, Journal of Applied Biomaterials and Functional Materials, 2020).
Lithium disilicate is the material family that includes e.max, which Lumi uses, and the samples in the first of these studies were e.max ceramic. Lumi provides onlays, and our article on what a dental onlay is explains how they differ from fillings and crowns.
When a new onlay is the better option
A replacement is usually made when the old onlay is cracked, when decay or a fracture means the tooth needs reshaping, or when the onlay no longer seats properly. A new onlay starts with a new scan or impression of the prepared tooth. If the tooth has dentine exposed, the dentist may seal it at that appointment; our article on immediate dentine sealing describes what that involves and what the trials show.
Questions patients ask
Can I use pharmacy temporary cement to put an onlay back?
It is best to ring the practice first. Temporary cement will not recreate the resin bond the onlay relies on, and the inside of the onlay and the tooth will need to be cleaned of it again before the onlay can be properly bonded.
Will the same thing happen again?
Not necessarily. Debonding was recorded in about 1% of ceramic inlays, onlays and overlays in the meta-analysis above. If there is a likely cause, such as decay, a crack or heavy grinding, dealing with that cause is part of the plan.
Is a rebonded onlay as strong as before?
Laboratory studies suggest the bond can be restored to a similar level when the surface is cleaned and treated again, but we did not find long-term clinical studies that answer this directly.
For dentists: cleaning the fitting surface before rebonding
Water spray alone did not restore bond strength to saliva-contaminated, hydrofluoric acid etched lithium disilicate, whereas phosphoric acid, a cleaning paste, a cleaning gel and silane applied before contamination all did (Yoshida, Clinical Oral Investigations, 2020). After contamination with saliva and a silicone disclosing material, re-etching with 5% hydrofluoric acid gave significantly higher bond strength than the other cleaning methods tested, in specimens stored for up to 150 days with thermocycling (Klosa and colleagues, Journal of Adhesive Dentistry, 2009). In a third study, a self-etching ceramic primer, with or without earlier hydrofluoric acid etching, and re-etching with hydrofluoric acid gave higher shear bond strength to lithium disilicate contaminated with saliva and try-in paste than the other methods, although no method removed every trace of contamination (Del Bianco and colleagues, Journal of Adhesive Dentistry, 2024).
A practical point from these studies: if an intact lithium disilicate onlay has been tried in, a water rinse alone may not be enough before bonding, and re-etching with hydrofluoric acid or a self-etching ceramic primer gave the highest bond strengths. The limits: all three are in vitro studies on laboratory specimens with simulated contamination, not debonded clinical restorations carrying old cement, and none followed rebonded onlays in patients.
Getting it looked at
If an onlay has come off, keep it and book a visit at our Melrose Park practice so the tooth and the onlay can both be checked. You can book online or read more about crowns and partial coverage restorations at Lumi.
Sources
- Morimoto S and colleagues. Survival rate of resin and ceramic inlays, onlays, and overlays: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Dental Research, 2016. PubMed 27287305
- Abduo J and Sambrook RJ. Longevity of ceramic onlays: a systematic review. Journal of Esthetic and Restorative Dentistry, 2018. PubMed 29676497
- Scholz KJ and colleagues. Randomized clinical split-mouth study on the performance of CAD/CAM partial ceramic crowns luted with a self-adhesive resin cement or a universal adhesive and a conventional resin cement after 39 months. Journal of Dentistry, 2021. PubMed 34624421
- Alghauli MA and colleagues. Clinical reliability of self-adhesive luting resins compared to other adhesive procedures: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Dentistry, 2023. PubMed 36566829
- Pineda-Vásquez L and colleagues. Shear bond strength of debonded ceramic restorations re-cemented by means of a cleaning and retreatment protocol. Journal of Clinical and Experimental Dentistry, 2019. PubMed 31346369
- Albaker AM and colleagues. Bonding integrity and compressive strength of re-bonded, surface conditioned and Er,Cr:YSGG laser treated lithium disilicate ceramics. Journal of Applied Biomaterials and Functional Materials, 2020. PubMed 32421423
- Yoshida K. Influence of cleaning methods on the bond strength of resin cement to saliva-contaminated lithium disilicate ceramic. Clinical Oral Investigations, 2020. PubMed 31643001
- Klosa K and colleagues. The effect of storage conditions, contamination modes and cleaning procedures on the resin bond strength to lithium disilicate ceramic. Journal of Adhesive Dentistry, 2009. PubMed 19492714
- Del Bianco F and colleagues. Bond strength to lithium-disilicate ceramic after different surface cleaning approaches. Journal of Adhesive Dentistry, 2024. PubMed 38240152
- healthdirect. Toothache and gum swelling. healthdirect.gov.au









