In a randomised trial published in the British Journal of Orthodontics in 1998, Harradine and colleagues took young patients who had previously had orthodontic treatment, removed the wisdom teeth in one group and left them in the other, then measured the lower front teeth some years later. The difference in crowding between the groups was small and not considered clinically meaningful. Later systematic reviews, which rely mostly on observational studies, are mixed: most studies find no clear link, one meta-analysis suggests lower wisdom teeth may contribute a little, and none supports removing them just to prevent crowding.
Wisdom teeth can still cause real problems. Protecting a straight smile just is not a good reason on its own to take them out.
Why the idea was so convincing
Wisdom teeth usually arrive in the late teens or early twenties, often in a jaw with little room left. Around the same age, many people notice their lower front teeth starting to overlap. The two events happen together, and the explanation seemed obvious: the back teeth must be pushing the rest forward, like a row of dominoes.
For decades that reasoning led to wisdom teeth being removed early specifically to prevent crowding, sometimes before they had caused any trouble at all. When the theory was eventually tested directly, by comparing people who had their wisdom teeth removed with people who kept them, the domino effect did not show up in a meaningful way.

Front teeth crowd with age anyway
Mild crowding of the lower front teeth becomes more common through adult life, including in people who never developed wisdom teeth. Researchers have pointed to several likely contributors:
- Late jaw growth. Small changes in the growth of the upper and lower jaws continue into adulthood and can alter how the front teeth sit.
- Forward drift. Teeth have a natural tendency to move slightly forward over time, which narrows the space available at the front.
- Changes in support. Gradual changes in the gum and bone around teeth, and in the pressure from lips and tongue, can allow small shifts.
None of these depends on a wisdom tooth being present. That is why front teeth can drift after braces even when the wisdom teeth have been removed, and why long-term retainer wear is the main protection after orthodontic treatment. Our guide to retainers covers the options.
The problems wisdom teeth really can cause
Wisdom teeth are still removed often, for reasons tied to the tooth itself and the tooth beside it:
- impaction, where the tooth is stuck at an angle against the second molar;
- repeated infection of the gum over a partly erupted tooth;
- decay in the wisdom tooth, or in the back of the second molar where food and plaque collect;
- damage to the root of the second molar, or a cyst around an unerupted tooth, both less common.
These are assessed with a clinical examination and X-rays, often an OPG, and sometimes a 3D scan when the roots sit close to the nerve. Wisdom teeth that are fully erupted, healthy and easy to clean can often stay. If one does need to come out, our wisdom tooth recovery timeline describes what to expect.

If someone suggests removal to stop crowding
It is reasonable to ask what the recommendation is based on. A useful answer will describe the wisdom tooth itself: whether it is impacted, decayed, hard to clean, repeatedly inflamed, or harming the tooth next to it. If the main reason given is that it will keep your front teeth straight, it is fair to ask whether there is another reason, and to weigh that against the usual risks of surgery.
If your front teeth are already shifting and you want them straighter, that is a separate conversation about orthodontic treatment. Our guides to straightening crooked teeth and the costs of braces and aligners are a good starting point, and why teeth are removed before braces explains when extractions come into orthodontic planning.
Questions we are often asked
Can a wisdom tooth push on the tooth next to it?
Yes. An angled or impacted wisdom tooth can press on the second molar, trap food and cause decay or root damage there. That is a local problem at the back of the mouth, separate from crowding of the front teeth.
Were dentists wrong to remove wisdom teeth for crowding in the past?
The advice reflected the best understanding at the time. Once better-designed studies tested the idea directly, recommendations changed, which is how clinical knowledge is meant to develop.
Will taking my wisdom teeth out now keep my smile straight later?
The research does not show a dependable effect, so it should not be the only reason for removal. Retainers are more relevant if you have had braces or aligners.
If you would like to know if your wisdom teeth need attention, or you have noticed your teeth moving and want to understand why, our dentists in Melrose Park can examine them and explain what the X-rays show. See our current deals or read about general dentistry at Lumi Dental.
This article is general information and does not replace individual advice from your dentist or orthodontist.









