Orthodontic extractions come down to millimetres. If the teeth in an arch need more room than the jawbone offers, that space has to come from somewhere, and removing a tooth is one of several ways to find it. Many crowded smiles are now straightened without any extractions, so a recommendation to remove teeth should come with a clear explanation of why the alternatives do not fit your case.
Counting the space a smile needs
When a dentist plans braces or aligners, one of the first measurements compares the total width of the teeth with the length of the arch they need to fit into. A small shortfall can usually be absorbed. A large one cannot simply be wished away, because teeth pushed too far forward or outward can end up near the edge of the bone that supports them, which may raise the risk of gum recession and of the result relapsing.
There are only a handful of ways to create room:
- widen the arch;
- slim the teeth a little by polishing enamel between them;
- move back teeth further back;
- tip the front teeth slightly forward;
- remove one or more teeth.
Which mix suits a person depends on how much space is missing, the bite, the gums and bone, and the profile of the lips and face. Crowding is the most common reason for extractions, but they may also help when the upper front teeth stick out a long way or a tooth is stuck out of line.

The premolars are the usual choice
When extractions are part of the plan, the first premolars are chosen most often. These sit just behind the canines. They are close enough to the front to relieve crowding there, the remaining premolars and molars still do the chewing, and once the gaps close their absence is usually hard to notice in a smile.
Other teeth are sometimes chosen instead. A tooth that is badly decayed, heavily filled or stranded outside the arch may be the more sensible one to lose. Sometimes only upper teeth are removed, for example when the upper front teeth are well forward but the lower arch is fine. Your dentist should show you on your X-rays and scans exactly which teeth are involved and why.
Ways to make room without extractions
Widening the upper jaw
In children, a palatal expander can widen the upper jaw by separating it along the midpalatal suture, the seam running down the middle of the palate. That suture matures gradually through the teens, and the age at which this happens varies widely from one person to another; researchers such as Angelieri and colleagues (American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, 2013) have described it in stages from A to E. Conventional expanders become less effective as the suture matures. For older teenagers and adults, options include miniscrew-assisted expansion (MARPE), which Lumi places for suitable adults, or surgically assisted expansion. Our guides to palatal expanders and adult expansion with MARPE explain how each works, and early orthodontic treatment for children covers why timing matters.
Polishing between teeth
Interproximal reduction (IPR) removes a fraction of a millimetre of enamel from the sides of selected teeth. Across several teeth, this can add up to enough room for mild crowding. Our article on attachments and IPR describes the process.
Moving back teeth backwards
Small titanium anchors called temporary anchorage devices can give braces something stable to pull against, allowing molars to be moved back in selected cases. See our guide to orthodontic miniscrews.
Aligners for milder crowding
Mild to moderate crowding can often be treated with clear aligners using a combination of the methods above. Our comparison of braces and aligners for adults sets out where each tends to suit.
Each of these has limits. Expanding or advancing teeth too far can thin the gum and bone over the roots, make the lips look full or produce a result that is hard to hold. In some mouths, removing two or four teeth gives a more stable and more natural-looking result than avoiding extraction at any cost.
Wisdom teeth are a separate question
It is commonly believed that wisdom teeth push the front teeth crooked. The evidence is mixed: a 2024 review of observational studies (Palikaraki and colleagues, Angle Orthodontist) suggested lower wisdom teeth may contribute to some lower front crowding, but the studies carried a moderate to high risk of bias, and many other factors play a part. Our article on wisdom teeth and crowding looks at this in more detail. Wisdom teeth may still be removed during orthodontic care if they are impacted, causing problems, or in the way of moving the molars back. That is a different decision from removing premolars to relieve crowding.

How the extraction fits into treatment
The decision is made after records are taken: photographs, a 3D scan and X-rays to measure crowding and assess the bite. You should be shown the plan with and without extractions, including how long each is likely to take and how each may affect your profile. If extractions go ahead, they are usually done shortly before or soon after the braces are fitted, depending on the plan.
Removing a premolar is usually a routine procedure under local anaesthetic. Most people are sore for a few days and manage with simple pain relief and soft food; our extraction recovery timeline describes normal healing. The spaces are then closed by the braces over many months, using elastic chains or springs. Treatment with extractions can take longer than without, but that varies from case to case. Retainers afterwards help keep the spaces closed.
Fair questions to ask before agreeing
You are entitled to understand the reasoning. Useful questions include: how much space is missing, and how was it measured? Which teeth would be removed? What would a non-extraction plan involve, and what are its risks for the gums and the stability of the result? How would each option affect the lips and profile? Seeing your own scans while these points are explained often makes the choice much clearer.
Other questions patients ask
Will taking teeth out make my face look sunken?
A well-planned case aims to keep the profile balanced. Where the front teeth and lips are very prominent, closing extraction spaces may make them less so, which is often one of the goals. Expected changes should be discussed before treatment starts.
Do the gaps always close fully?
Closing them is part of the plan and is usually achieved, though results vary. Wearing retainers as advised helps stop small gaps reopening.
Are extractions more common in children or adults?
Neither group automatically. In growing children, early treatment or expansion can sometimes reduce the need for extractions later. In adults, MARPE or other approaches may be options where they are suitable.
At Lumi Dental, our general dentists provide braces and clear aligners and take scans and X-rays in the practice to plan treatment. Complex cases may be referred to a registered orthodontist. If you have been told you may need teeth removed, or want to know whether aligners could work for you, book a free consult with our team in Melrose Park to go through the options.









