A sore wisdom tooth is a reason to have it looked at, not automatically a reason to have it out. Plenty of wisdom teeth ache for a few days while they come through and then settle. What decides whether one should be removed is what the dentist finds on examination and X-ray, such as repeated infection, decay that cannot be fixed or damage to the tooth in front.
Some wisdom teeth never need to come out
The Victorian Government's Better Health Channel puts it plainly: some wisdom teeth do not cause problems and do not need to be taken out. A wisdom tooth that has come through fully, meets the opposing tooth and can be brushed and flossed like any other molar can often stay. In the United Kingdom, the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) advised back in 2000 that impacted wisdom teeth without disease should not be removed just in case, and that surgery should be limited to teeth with evidence of a problem.
So pain is a signal to find the cause. The cause, rather than the pain, guides the decision.
Pain that often settles with time and good cleaning
Several common causes of wisdom tooth discomfort are short-lived:
- Eruption soreness. The gum over an erupting tooth can be tender and a little swollen for a few days at a time, then quieten down.
- Trapped food. Food caught between the wisdom tooth and the molar in front irritates the gum. Careful cleaning with a small interdental brush often settles it.
- A bite on the gum flap. An upper wisdom tooth can knock against the gum covering a lower one. Smoothing a sharp cusp or treating the gum may be enough.
If symptoms like these come and go, a dentist may suggest monitoring the tooth with regular check-ups and X-rays. Our article on watching and waiting with wisdom teeth explains what monitoring involves.
Signs the tooth is more likely to need removal
NICE lists the kinds of problems that justify taking an impacted wisdom tooth out. They include decay that cannot be restored, infection in the tooth's nerve or root that cannot be treated, abscess or spreading infection, damage to the roots of the neighbouring tooth, a fractured tooth, and a cyst or other disease in the sac around the tooth.
Pericoronitis, an infection of the gum flap over a partly erupted tooth, is a common reason people notice pain. The NICE guidance says a single mild episode is not, on its own, a reason for surgery, but a second or later episode is generally considered an appropriate reason. Our guide to wisdom tooth gum infections covers this in more detail.
One reason that is often given is not well supported. The idea that wisdom teeth push the front teeth out of line is widely believed, but a randomised trial by Harradine and colleagues (British Journal of Orthodontics, 1998) concluded that removing wisdom teeth to prevent late crowding of the lower front teeth cannot be justified. That is a separate topic, covered in our article on wisdom teeth and crowding.

Easing mild pain until you are seen
Warm salty water held in the mouth helps keep the area clean. A soft toothbrush and an interdental brush can clear food from around the tooth without scraping the gum. Over-the-counter pain relief, used exactly as the packet directs, can take the edge off; our comparison of ibuprofen and paracetamol for tooth pain explains the differences, and a pharmacist can advise if you take other medicines. These measures buy time. They do not treat an infection or a decayed tooth.
Do not wait if you notice these
Book an urgent appointment, or go to a hospital emergency department if you cannot reach a dentist, if you have:
- swelling of the cheek, jaw or under the tongue
- a fever or feel generally unwell
- trouble opening your mouth or swallowing
- pus coming from the gum around the tooth
Difficulty breathing or swallowing with facial swelling is a medical emergency; call 000. Lumi offers emergency appointments for urgent dental pain. If the ache is worst when you lie down, our article on toothache at night explains why that happens.
Questions about keeping wisdom teeth
Can a painful wisdom tooth be kept?
Often, if the pain came from eruption or trapped food and the tooth is upright, fully through and cleanable. If X-rays show decay, bone loss or a cyst, removal is more likely to be advised.
How many infections are too many?
Under the NICE guidance, a first mild episode of pericoronitis is usually managed without surgery, while a second or later episode is generally a reasonable indication for removal. Your dentist will also consider how severe each episode was.
Does removal always mean surgery?
No. A wisdom tooth that is fully through can often be removed much like any other tooth. A tooth that is impacted or sits close to the nerve usually needs a surgical approach, and for some lower teeth a coronectomy, where only the crown is removed, may be an option.
Sources
- Better Health Channel (Victorian Government). Wisdom teeth.
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Guidance on the extraction of wisdom teeth (TA1), 2000.
- Harradine NW, et al. The effect of extraction of third molars on late lower incisor crowding: a randomized controlled trial. British Journal of Orthodontics, 1998;25(2):117 to 122.
Find out what is causing the pain
An examination and X-ray are the only way to know whether a sore wisdom tooth can stay. You can read about wisdom teeth care at Lumi Dental in Melrose Park, see what to expect if removal is advised in our extraction recovery guide, or check the current deals before you book.









