Two cavities can sit the same distance from the nerve on an X-ray and still end up with different treatment. One tooth gets a filling and carries on for years; the other needs a root canal. The difference is the condition of the pulp, the living tissue in the centre of the tooth, and whether it can still settle down once the decay is gone.
That is why a dentist will not promise a filling or a root canal from the X-ray alone. The decision comes from the picture, your symptoms and a few simple tests taken together.
Inflamed is not the same as finished
As decay creeps towards the pulp, bacterial by-products reach it through the dentine and the pulp becomes inflamed. Early on, this inflammation is reversible: remove the decay, seal the tooth well, and the pulp can recover. Once it becomes irreversible, or the pulp has died, it will not heal by itself, and keeping the tooth means root canal treatment.
Most of what happens at the appointment is aimed at working out which side of that line your tooth is on.
Clues from how the tooth feels
Symptoms point in a direction, but they are not a diagnosis, and teeth do not always follow the pattern.
- A short zing with cold or sweet that is gone within seconds usually fits a pulp that is healthy or only mildly irritated.
- Sensitivity that hangs around well after the cold has gone suggests the pulp is more inflamed.
- Pain that starts on its own, throbs, or wakes you at night often means the inflammation is beyond recovery.
- Pain on biting, a pimple on the gum or swelling can mean infection has spread past the root tip.
- No symptoms at all does not rule anything out. Deep decay can be completely painless.
Facial swelling or fever needs urgent care the same day, and difficulty breathing, speaking or swallowing needs a hospital emergency department straight away.
The X-ray shows depth, not inflammation
An X-ray shows how much tooth has been lost, how near the decay appears to be to the pulp chamber, and any change in the bone at the root tip that may suggest infection. It cannot show whether the pulp is inflamed. A lesion that looks as though it touches the pulp sometimes still has a thin layer of sound dentine over it, and the reverse also happens. So the dentist adds cold testing, tapping and a check of the gum around the tooth to what the image shows.
Many of these deep cavities start between teeth, where they are hard to see in a mirror. Our article on cavities between teeth explains why bitewing X-rays pick them up.

If the pulp is healthy: a filling, with less drilling near the nerve
The old approach was to drill out every bit of softened dentine. In a very deep cavity that often opened into the pulp. Today, many dentists use selective removal: the decay is cleared completely from the outer walls so the filling seals properly, and a layer of leathery or firm dentine is left over the pulp. Sealed off from food, the bacteria left under the filling have little to live on.
A 2021 Cochrane review (Schwendicke and colleagues, 27 studies) found fewer failures in adult teeth with selective or stepwise removal than with complete removal, although most of the evidence was rated low or very low certainty. Stepwise removal means the tooth is treated in two visits months apart: most of the decay is removed and the tooth sealed, then it is reopened to remove what is left. In the same review, stepwise removal had more failures than selective removal in adult teeth, so where a single visit is suitable, selective removal is often preferred.
If the pulp is exposed but healthy: a pulp cap
Sometimes a pinpoint of pulp is exposed during treatment, or the remaining dentine is paper thin. If the pulp looks healthy and the bleeding stops readily, the dentist may place a calcium silicate cement such as Biodentine directly over it before the filling. These materials seal the area and can encourage the pulp to lay down a bridge of new hard tissue. At Lumi we use bioceramic materials, including Biodentine, for this kind of pulp protection when the tooth is suitable. The European Society of Endodontology's 2019 position statement on deep caries puts the emphasis on keeping the pulp alive and healthy wherever that is realistic.
Pulp capping is not for every tooth. Heavy bleeding that will not settle, or symptoms that suggest a badly inflamed pulp, usually point to another treatment. Our guides to pulp capping and vital pulp therapy go into more detail.

If the pulp cannot recover: root canal treatment
Root canal treatment is recommended when the signs point to irreversible inflammation or a dead pulp: spontaneous or night pain, pain that lingers long after hot or cold, no response to testing, swelling, or a dark area at the root tip on the X-ray. The pulp is removed, the canals are cleaned, shaped and sealed, and the tooth is rebuilt, often with a crown on a back tooth.
It is done under local anaesthetic, and for many people it is far more comfortable than the toothache that led to it. Our article on whether a root canal hurts covers what to expect.
If the tooth cannot be rebuilt: extraction
Removing the tooth becomes the realistic choice when too little sound tooth is left to restore, a crack runs deep below the gum, or previous treatment has failed and cannot be redone. Keeping a natural tooth is usually preferred when it is reasonable, but an unrestorable tooth can keep getting infected. Our comparison of root canal versus extraction lays out the trade-offs.
Typical costs for each path
These are typical Australian market ranges, not Lumi Dental fees. The cost for your tooth depends on which tooth it is, how much is missing and whether a crown is needed.
| Treatment | Typical market range |
|---|---|
| Filling, with or without a pulp cap | Usually the least expensive option; depends on size and material |
| Root canal treatment | About $1,000 (front tooth) to $3,000 (molar) |
| Crown after a root canal | $1,500 to $2,500 |
| Extraction | $200 to $350 simple, $400 to $900 surgical, plus the cost of any replacement |
Health fund rebates may apply.
Questions we are often asked
Can I tell at home whether the decay has reached the nerve?
Not reliably. Lingering pain, night pain and swelling are warning signs, but the answer comes from an examination, tests and X-rays.
Will a deep cavity heal if I leave it?
No. A cavity that has broken into dentine does not repair itself. Very early decay can sometimes be stopped, as our article on reversing early decay explains, but a deep cavity tends to keep moving towards the pulp, which can lead to an abscess and loss of the tooth.
Is a pulp cap a cheaper version of a root canal?
They do different jobs. A pulp cap tries to keep a healthy pulp alive; a root canal is for a pulp that cannot recover. Neither one is better in every case.
Have the tooth checked before it decides for you
If you have been told about a deep cavity, or a tooth has started reacting to cold, our dentists at Lumi Dental in Melrose Park can examine it and explain which path applies and why. Read about our general dentistry, or see the new patient offer on the current deals page. You will usually receive a written treatment plan, often by email, before treatment starts.









