Pulling a tooth almost always costs less on the day than saving it, and that price gap is why so many people ask for the extraction. The comparison changes once you count what usually follows: most lost back teeth are eventually replaced, and a replacement often costs as much as the root canal and crown would have. Before money comes into it, though, the deciding question is clinical. Can this particular tooth be restored and kept working for years?
Start with whether the tooth can be restored
A root canal only makes sense if there is enough sound tooth left to rebuild. Your dentist judges this from an X-ray and a close look at the tooth, checking how deep the decay or crack goes, whether the damage runs below the gum line, how much solid wall remains above the bone and how healthy the surrounding gum and bone are.
A molar with a deep cavity that has reached the nerve, but still has thick walls, is often a good candidate for saving. A tooth split down the length of its root, or one so broken down that there is nothing left for a crown to hold onto, usually is not. Two people with the same throbbing toothache can end up with different recommendations once the X-ray is on the screen, which is why this is rarely something a dentist can answer over the phone.
Two very different treatments
Root canal treatment keeps the tooth in place
Inside every tooth is the pulp, the soft tissue with nerves and blood vessels. When it becomes inflamed or infected, it can cause severe pain and lead to an abscess. Root canal treatment removes that tissue under local anaesthetic, cleans and shapes the fine canals inside the roots, and seals them. The tooth itself, with its root still anchored in the bone, stays where it is and keeps working in your bite.
Back teeth that have had a root canal usually need a crown to protect what is left from splitting under chewing forces. This is not a minor add-on. In a study of root-filled teeth followed for up to about ten years, Aquilino and Caplan (Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry, 2002) found that teeth left without a crown were lost at about six times the rate of crowned teeth. Front teeth can sometimes be restored with a filling instead. Our guide to root canal treatment walks through the appointments in more detail.
Extraction removes the problem and leaves a space
A simple extraction, where the tooth is whole and easy to reach, is usually quick and done under local anaesthetic. A surgical extraction is needed when a tooth has broken off at the gum or has curved or awkward roots, and it may involve a small cut in the gum and stitches. Either way, the source of the pain or infection is gone.
The space that remains is the part people tend to underestimate. Neighbouring teeth can tip into the gap, the opposing tooth can drift towards it, and the bone where the root used to sit gradually shrinks. That is why extraction often opens a second decision about whether, and how, to fill the space. Our articles on extraction costs and the extraction recovery timeline cover that path.
How long a saved tooth tends to last
No dentist can promise a lifespan for any tooth, but the research is encouraging. A systematic review by Ng and colleagues (International Endodontic Journal, 2010) pooled studies of teeth after root canal treatment and found that between 86% and 93% were still in the mouth two to ten years later. The factors most strongly linked to a tooth surviving were having a crown placed afterwards, having neighbouring teeth on both sides, and not being used to support a bridge or denture. Molars did somewhat less well than other teeth.
Retreating a root canal that has failed is possible, and so is a small surgical procedure at the root tip called an apicoectomy. Both can work well, but the outlook depends on why the first treatment failed. When a previously treated tooth flares up and also has other problems, such as a crack or little sound tooth left, extraction is more often the sensible choice.
What each path typically costs
The figures below are typical Australian market ranges, not Lumi fees. Root canal fees rise from front teeth to molars because molars have more canals, and each canal adds time.
| Treatment | Typical market range |
|---|---|
| Root canal treatment | About $1,000 (front tooth) to $3,000 (molar) |
| Crown after root canal | $1,500 to $2,500 |
| Simple extraction | $200 to $350 |
| Surgical extraction | $400 to $900 |
| Single implant with crown | $4,000 to $7,000 |
| Three-unit bridge | $3,500 to $6,500 |
Put together, saving a tooth with a root canal and crown often lands somewhere around $2,500 for a front tooth to $5,500 for a molar. Removing the same tooth may cost a few hundred dollars, but adding an implant brings the total to roughly $4,200 to $7,900, and a bridge to about $3,700 to $7,400. A removable partial denture is usually the lowest cost replacement, although many people find a plate a poor swap for a single fixed back tooth. Leaving the gap costs nothing upfront, yet any drifting or bite changes that follow can mean more involved treatment later.
So on cost alone, keeping a restorable tooth is often similar to or less than replacing it with something fixed, and you keep your own root and the bone around it. Replacement pricing is covered in more depth in our guides to dental implants, bridges and dentures.
Many extras policies contribute to both treatments, usually with extractions under general dental and root canals and crowns under major dental. Waiting periods for major dental are commonly 12 months, but each fund sets its own, so check with yours. Medicare does not cover routine dental care for most adults. Our article on health insurance for dental explains how extras cover works.
Teeth that are usually worth keeping
Saving the tooth tends to be the better option when the pulp is damaged but the tooth itself is structurally sound: a deep cavity or an old knock that has reached the nerve, a good amount of natural tooth above the gum, and healthy gum and bone around the root.
Front teeth deserve particular thought. A gap at the front is obvious straight away, and even a well-made replacement is never quite the same as your own tooth. Keeping the root also keeps the bone around it, which matters for appearance and for any future implant if one is ever needed.
Teeth that are often better removed
Treating a tooth that is very likely to fail helps nobody. Extraction is usually the more sensible path when:
- the tooth has split vertically into the root
- so little structure is left that a crown has nothing to grip
- advanced gum disease has already loosened it in the bone
- a previous root canal has failed and retreatment has poor odds
- it is a wisdom tooth causing trouble, since these do little for chewing and are awkward to treat
A tooth right at the back that does not meet an opposing tooth can sometimes be removed and simply not replaced. That is a reasonable choice for some people, and your dentist can tell you whether it is likely to affect your bite.
Filling the gap if the tooth comes out
If extraction is the better choice for a tooth that matters to your chewing or your smile, it is worth knowing the replacement options before the appointment, because they shape both the plan and the total cost.
An implant is a titanium post placed in the jawbone with a crown attached once it has bonded to the bone. It stands on its own without involving the neighbouring teeth and is the closest thing to a natural tooth, but it costs the most, usually takes several months from start to finish and needs enough healthy bone. Dental implants are placed at Lumi, and a 3D scan helps show whether there is enough bone in the right place.
A bridge fills the space with a false tooth fixed to crowns on the teeth either side. It is fixed and usually quicker than an implant, but those neighbouring teeth have to be shaped to hold it, which is a real cost if they were healthy to begin with.
A partial denture is a removable plate carrying the false tooth. It is the least invasive and usually the lowest cost option, and it can replace several teeth at once. It is also less stable than a fixed option and needs to come out for cleaning.
Each of these can work well. None of them is free, and each one is doing a job your own tooth was doing before it was lost.
Beliefs that can steer the decision the wrong way
"Taking it out is always cheaper." It is cheaper on the day. Once a tooth is replaced with an implant or bridge, the total is often the same as or more than saving it.
"Once it is out, the problem is over." The painful tooth is gone, but the space can allow nearby teeth to move and the bone to shrink, which can create new problems over the years.
"Root-filled teeth do not last." A root-filled tooth that is well sealed and crowned commonly lasts many years, as the survival figures above show. It is not guaranteed, and nor is any other tooth or replacement.
"An abscess means the tooth has to go." Many abscessed teeth can be saved once the infection is treated through the root canal. The decision still depends on how much sound tooth is left.
When it is a close call
Between the obvious cases sits a group of teeth where either choice can be defended. A tooth that needs a post, or surgery on the gum to expose enough tooth for a crown, is a weaker candidate than one with solid walls. Heavy teeth grinding puts extra load on a restored tooth. If you are already planning an implant next door, the sums may look different. Time matters too: a root canal and crown usually means two or three visits, while an extraction is often one visit with any replacement later.
In these situations a useful question for your dentist is which option keeps more of your own healthy tooth, and what the realistic chances are that it lasts. You should come away understanding both options well enough to choose.
Cracks, abscesses and other special cases
A cracked tooth sits right on the line. A crack confined to the crown can often be managed with a root canal and crown, while a crack that runs down into the root usually means extraction. The depth of the crack decides it, and sometimes that is only clear once treatment begins.
An abscess means infection has spread beyond the tooth into the surrounding tissue. It does not automatically mean the tooth must go, and many abscessed teeth are saved with root canal treatment. It does mean you should be seen promptly, especially if you have facial swelling or a fever.
Wisdom teeth are their own topic, and our wisdom teeth guide explains when removal is advised.
Pain during treatment and afterwards
Root canal treatment has a reputation it does not really deserve. It is done under local anaesthetic, and for most people it feels much like having a large filling. The pain people remember is usually the infection in the days before treatment. Some tenderness for a few days afterwards is common and generally settles with over-the-counter pain relief.
An extraction is also done under local anaesthetic. Afterwards there is a healing socket, some swelling and a few care steps to lower the risk of dry socket. Surgical extractions usually take longer to settle than simple ones. Pain that gets worse after a few days, rather than better, is a reason to call your dentist.
Questions we are often asked
Is a tooth dead after a root canal?
The pulp is removed, so the tooth no longer has living tissue at its centre. It stays firmly anchored by its root and the surrounding bone, and it keeps working in your bite like any other tooth.
Can I have the extraction now and decide on a replacement later?
Yes, and many people do. It helps to discuss replacement options before the extraction, though, because some choices, such as an implant, work best when the site is planned for from the start.
Why does a root canal cost so much more than pulling the tooth?
Cleaning and sealing narrow canals inside the roots takes time and precision, and back teeth usually need a crown afterwards. An extraction is quicker. The difference narrows, and sometimes reverses, once you add the cost of replacing the tooth.
Is it safe to wait and see?
If a tooth is painful, swollen or keeping you awake, waiting usually makes the decision harder, because decay and infection can spread and leave less tooth to save. Pain that suddenly stops is not always a good sign either, as it can mean the nerve has died. It is best to be seen soon.
What if I am anxious about either procedure?
Tell your dentist early. Both treatments are routinely done under local anaesthetic, and sedation can help some people. IV sedation and happy gas (relative analgesia) are available at Lumi, and we can talk through which options might suit you.
Weighing it up with your dentist
At Lumi Dental we take a 3D X-ray or OPG on our Orthophos unit when it will help, show you what it shows, and explain both paths, including the likely costs and how long each option might last. You will usually receive a written treatment plan, often by email, so you can think it over before deciding. If you are weighing up a root canal against an extraction, you can book a consultation at our Melrose Park practice and talk it through.
This article is general information and not a substitute for personal dental advice. Outcomes vary between individuals, and only an examination can determine the right option for your tooth.









