Book Online

All health funds accepted · Payment plans available, humm from $0 deposit · CDBS bulk billing

All health funds accepted · Payment plans available, humm from $0 deposit · CDBS bulk billing

Book online

Dentist examining a patient's teeth with a mouth mirror and probe

THE LUMI BLOG

Who isn't a good candidate for dental implants

Most people who are turned down for dental implants are told to wait rather than refused outright, and gum disease, bone loss, smoking, diabetes and some medicines are the usual reasons.

Dr James Tran, dentist at Lumi Dental Melrose Park

Dr James Tran

August 15, 2026 · Implants · 6 min read

Very few people are ruled out of dental implants for good. Far more are told "not yet", because something in their mouth or general health needs attention before an implant has a fair chance of lasting. So the more useful thing to ask is what would need to change first.

Below are the situations where a dentist is most likely to pause or decline implant treatment, roughly from the most common to the less common, along with what tends to happen next.

Gum disease that is still active

This is one of the most frequent reasons to wait. The bacteria and inflammation behind periodontitis do not stop at natural teeth; implants can develop a similar problem in the surrounding gum and bone, called peri-implantitis. Placing an implant while the disease is active asks a new root to settle into an inflamed environment.

A history of gum disease also matters after it has been treated. A 2014 meta-analysis in the Journal of Dentistry (Chrcanovic and colleagues) pooled 22 studies and found implant failure in about 5.4% of implants placed in people with a history of periodontitis, compared with about 3.8% in people without it. The authors noted all of the included studies carried a high risk of bias, so the figures are best read as a signal rather than a precise forecast. In practice, it means getting the gums stable first and committing to regular maintenance afterwards.

Not enough bone where the tooth used to be

Once a tooth is lost, the ridge of bone that held it tends to shrink, sometimes quickly in the first months. Old extractions, long-standing gum disease and wearing a denture over the area can all leave the bone too narrow or too shallow for an implant of a normal size. In the upper back jaw, the sinus can also sit close to the ridge.

This is a hurdle more often than a barrier. Bone grafting, a sinus lift or guided bone regeneration can rebuild the site, usually over several months, before or at the same time as the implant goes in. It adds time and cost, so the plan is mapped out on a 3D scan first. Our guide to bone density and dental implants goes through how low bone is measured and managed.

A patient standing in a 3D dental X-ray machine at Lumi Dental
A 3D X-ray shows the height and width of the jawbone, which decides whether an implant can go in straight away or needs grafting first.

Smoking, especially heavy smoking

Smoking reduces blood flow to the gums and bone, and healing around a new implant depends on that blood supply. A 2015 Journal of Dentistry meta-analysis (Chrcanovic and colleagues) of 107 studies found about 6.4% of implants failed in smokers against about 3.2% in non-smokers, with more infections and more bone loss in smokers as well. Again, the authors cautioned that other factors could not be fully separated out.

Smokers do have successful implants. Stopping, or at least stopping for the period around surgery and healing, is one of the few risk factors a patient can change directly, and it is worth raising early so there is time to plan.

Diabetes that is poorly controlled

A diabetes diagnosis on its own is not a reason to refuse an implant. In a 2014 systematic review in the Journal of Dental Research, Chrcanovic and colleagues found no significant difference in implant failure between people with and without diabetes, though people with diabetes showed slightly more bone loss around their implants (about 0.2 mm on average). The authors cautioned that good comparative studies were scarce.

Where blood sugar is running high, wound healing slows and infection is more likely, so a dentist will usually want to see your recent control, often through your HbA1c result, and may liaise with your GP before going ahead.

Medicines that affect the jawbone

Antiresorptive medicines, such as bisphosphonates and denosumab, slow bone turnover. They carry a small risk of medication-related osteonecrosis of the jaw (MRONJ), an area of bone that fails to heal after oral surgery. At the lower doses used for osteoporosis the risk is low: a 2026 Asia-Pacific consensus statement (Taguchi and colleagues, Osteoporosis and Sarcopenia) reported annual rates of roughly 0.03% to 0.14%. The high doses used to treat cancer that has spread to bone carry a much higher risk, and elective implant surgery is generally avoided in that setting.

Because the answer depends on the exact medicine, dose and how long it has been taken, your dentist will want a full medication list and may speak with your doctor. Do not stop any medicine without your doctor's advice. Our article on bisphosphonates and jaw health has more detail.

A jaw that is still growing

An implant behaves like an ankylosed tooth: it stays exactly where it is placed. Natural teeth keep moving with jaw growth, so an implant placed in a teenager can end up sitting higher than its neighbours as the face matures. Implants are therefore usually delayed until growth has finished, which is generally the late teens or later and is checked rather than assumed.

Until then, a removable temporary tooth can hold the space. Our guide to flipper teeth and temporary partial dentures explains how they work.

Heavy grinding or clenching

A natural tooth sits in a cushioning ligament; an implant is joined directly to bone and has no such give. Strong grinding or clenching can overload the implant and its crown, and bruxism is often listed as a risk factor for mechanical problems such as loosened screws or chipped porcelain, though the research on implant loss itself is mixed. It rarely rules implants out. More often it shapes the plan: a protective night splint, a stronger crown design and closer reviews.

When the answer is "not yet" rather than "no"

Most of the situations above can be worked on. Gum disease can be treated and kept stable, bone can be rebuilt, smoking can be stopped, blood sugar can be brought under control and grinding can be managed. A smaller group of people, for example those having high-dose bone medicines for cancer or with very recent radiotherapy to the jaw, may be better served by another option altogether.

If an implant is not the right choice for now, a bridge or a denture can still replace the tooth well. Our comparison of implants, bridges and dentures sets out the trade-offs, and the dental implant cost guide explains what drives the overall price, including grafting.

Common questions

Is there an upper age limit for implants?

No. Older adults can and do have implants. General health, bone and how well someone can clean around the implant matter more than age, although healing may be slower and a review of 10-year studies (Howe and colleagues, Journal of Dentistry, 2019) found somewhat lower survival in people aged 65 and over.

Can I have an implant if I had gum disease years ago?

Often yes, once the gums are stable. The risk of problems is higher than for someone who never had gum disease, so regular maintenance visits with a dentist or OHT become part of the plan.

Should I stop my osteoporosis medicine before an implant?

Not on your own. The 2026 Asia-Pacific consensus statement found that evidence for a break from these medicines before dental surgery is still insufficient, so any change should be decided with your doctor.

How do I find out if I am suitable?

An examination, a review of your medical history and a 3D scan of the jaw answer most of the question. Some people also need gum treatment or a blood test result before a final plan is set.

Finding out where you stand

A list like this can only describe general risks; your own suitability comes down to an examination and a scan. Lumi Dental offers a free implant consult at Melrose Park, where we can look at your bone and gums and explain what, if anything, needs to happen first. Read more about dental implants at Lumi or see current offers to book.

Dr James Tran, dentist at Lumi Dental, Melrose Park

Written by Dr James Tran

Dr James Tran (BDent, University of Sydney; Graduate Diploma in Oral Implants) is a general dentist at Lumi Dental in Melrose Park. The team writes these articles to give clear, evidence-based dental information to help you make informed decisions about your care.

Inside Lumi Dental, Melrose Park

New patients

Your first visit is $149

A full 60 minute first visit with a check-up, clean, X-rays and a treatment plan. Usually $654, offer ends 31 December 2026. With most health funds there is no gap.

Open Monday to Saturday, and until 9:30pm on Thursdays. Free undercover parking at Melrose Central.