Book Online

All health funds accepted · Payment plans available, humm from $0 deposit · CDBS bulk billing

All health funds accepted · Payment plans available, humm from $0 deposit · CDBS bulk billing

Book online

Lumi Dental treatment room with a 3D scan of the teeth on the screen

THE LUMI BLOG

Pinhole gum surgery vs gum graft: which is right for receding gums?

How pinhole gum surgery and connective tissue grafts each cover exposed roots, what the evidence shows, who tends to suit which, and why the cause of recession comes first.

Dr James Tran, dentist at Lumi Dental Melrose Park

Dr James Tran

October 3, 2026 · Patient Education · 6 min read

If your teeth have started to look longer near the gum line, you may be weighing up two quite different ways to cover the exposed roots. A connective tissue graft takes a thin layer of tissue from the roof of the mouth and tucks it over the root; it has decades of independent research behind it. Pinhole gum surgery slides your existing gum down through a small opening, avoiding a second wound, but the research on it is newer and smaller. Neither will last unless the cause of the recession is dealt with first.

Recession exposes root surface that was never meant to be on show

Gum recession means the gum edge has moved down the tooth and uncovered part of the root. Roots have no enamel, so they are softer, wear more easily, decay more readily and are often sensitive to cold. Recession usually creeps up slowly and painlessly, which is why it is often first noticed at a routine check-up with a general dentist. Lost gum does not grow back by itself, as our article on whether receding gums can grow back explains.

Bone between the teeth decides how much can be covered

Before any surgery, recession is graded to predict how much root can realistically be covered. You may hear the older Miller classes or the newer system proposed by Cairo and colleagues in 2011 (Journal of Clinical Periodontology), which grades recession by the attachment level between the teeth:

  • No loss of attachment between the teeth (Cairo RT1, broadly Miller I and II): the best chance of full coverage.
  • Some loss between the teeth (RT2): partial coverage is often possible, full coverage less predictable.
  • Greater loss between the teeth (RT3): coverage is usually limited, and the focus shifts to comfort and stability.

The grade matters more than the technique, because no gum procedure replaces lost bone.

Find the cause before fixing the gum

Covering a root without changing what caused the recession risks it happening again. Common contributors include:

  • brushing too hard, with a hard-bristled brush or a scrubbing action
  • gum disease, which destroys the bone and gum supporting the teeth
  • clenching and grinding
  • orthodontic movement that pushes teeth, often lower front teeth, towards the edge of the bone
  • naturally thin gum, which is more vulnerable to all of the above

A soft brush and gentle technique, treating any gum disease and a night guard where advised can all help. A low-abrasion desensitising toothpaste can ease sensitivity; see our guide to the best toothpaste for receding gums, and our article on gum recession causes and treatment for more on prevention.

A dentist in a mask and gloves treating a young patient in a dental chair
A gum assessment measures the recession and looks for its cause before any treatment is planned.

A connective tissue graft adds new tissue

In a connective tissue graft, a thin piece of tissue is taken from beneath the surface of the palate and placed under the gum around the exposed root, then stitched in place. As well as covering the root, it thickens the gum, which may make the area more resistant to further recession. Donor tissue or collagen substitutes are sometimes used instead of your own tissue.

The main drawback is the second wound in the palate, which is usually the sorest part of recovery and takes longer to settle than the treated tooth. The 2018 Cochrane review of root coverage procedures (Chambrone and colleagues) found that where both root coverage and extra firm gum are wanted, connective tissue grafts show a slight advantage over other techniques. Our gum graft surgery guide walks through the procedure.

Pinhole surgery moves the gum you already have

The pinhole surgical technique was described by Dr John Chao in 2012 (International Journal of Periodontics and Restorative Dentistry). A small hole is made in the gum above the teeth, and instruments passed through it loosen the gum so it can be eased down over the roots. Strips of collagen are tucked in through the opening to help hold the gum in place. There is no donor site and usually no stitches, and several neighbouring teeth can often be treated through one or two openings.

Because it relies on repositioning existing tissue, it needs enough healthy gum to work with, and it does not add thickness the way a graft does.

Pinhole surgeryConnective tissue graft
What happensExisting gum is eased down through a small opening and held with collagen stripsTissue from the palate is placed under the gum over the root
Second woundNonePalate
StitchesUsually noneYes
RecoveryNo palate wound to healThe palate wound adds soreness
Gum thickeningLimitedYes
EvidenceSmaller and newer, often involving the technique's inventorLarge, independent and long-standing

What the comparison studies show so far

A split-mouth randomised trial by Shibly and colleagues (Compendium of Continuing Education in Dentistry, 2025) treated 36 people with recession on both sides, using pinhole surgery on one side and a flap with connective tissue graft on the other. At one year, root coverage was similar with both methods, and patient-reported outcomes did not differ significantly; only the graft side showed a significant gain in firm gum. Dr Chao was one of the authors, and independent long-term data on pinhole results remain limited. That does not mean the technique does not work; it means there is less certainty about how results hold over many years.

Matching the technique to the situation

A graft may suit people with thin gum that would benefit from thickening, a single deep recession, recession after orthodontic treatment, or anyone who prefers the most established option. Pinhole surgery may suit mild to moderate recession across several neighbouring teeth where there is enough healthy gum and a strong wish to avoid a palate wound, accepting the smaller evidence base. Sometimes neither is needed: minor, stable recession that is not sensitive can simply be monitored.

Fees for both vary widely with the number of teeth and the practitioner, and are usually quoted after an assessment. Our article on gum graft cost and recovery explains what affects the fee. Both procedures are usually carried out by periodontists or practitioners with specific training; our guide to dental specialists describes what a periodontist does. If you are considering either, ask how often the practitioner performs it and what result they expect for your grade of recession.

Clinical photographs being taken in the photo room at Lumi Dental
Clinical photographs help record recession so any change can be compared over time.

Questions about recession treatment

Which lasts longer, pinhole or a graft?

Long-term comparisons are limited. For any root coverage procedure, results depend heavily on controlling the cause, such as brushing force or gum disease, afterwards.

Is a gum graft very painful?

Most discomfort comes from the palate rather than the treated tooth. It is usually managed with pain relief, a soft diet and sometimes a protective plate.

Can recession be managed without surgery?

Lost gum does not regrow, but recession can often be slowed or stopped with gentle brushing, gum disease treatment and management of grinding. Sensitivity can be eased with desensitising toothpaste or bonding over exposed roots.

If your teeth look longer or feel more sensitive, a gum check is a sensible first step. The team at Lumi Dental can measure the recession, look for the cause, help you protect your gums at home and refer you to a periodontist if surgery may help. Book an examination with our general dentists in Melrose Park, or see our current deals page.

This article is general information only and is not a substitute for personalised advice from a registered dental practitioner.

Dr James Tran, dentist at Lumi Dental, Melrose Park

Written by Dr James Tran

Dr James Tran (BDent, University of Sydney; Graduate Diploma in Oral Implants) is a general dentist at Lumi Dental in Melrose Park. The team writes these articles to give clear, evidence-based dental information to help you make informed decisions about your care.

Inside Lumi Dental, Melrose Park

New patients

Your first visit is $149

A full 60 minute first visit with a check-up, clean, X-rays and a treatment plan. Usually $654, offer ends 31 December 2026. With most health funds there is no gap.

Open Monday to Saturday, and until 9:30pm on Thursdays. Free undercover parking at Melrose Central.