The real choice between same-day and conventional dentures is about timing. A same-day (immediate) denture goes in the moment your teeth come out, so you are never without teeth, but it is made to a guess at how your gums will heal. A conventional denture waits until the gums have settled, so you spend some weeks without teeth or with a basic temporary, but it is made to the shape your mouth actually ends up.
Two timelines
Same-day: denture first, healing after
Impressions are taken before the extractions, the denture is made in advance, and it is fitted at the same visit the teeth are removed. As the sockets heal, the gums and bone shrink, so the denture loosens and needs adjustments, soft linings and relines.
Conventional: healing first, denture after
The teeth come out, the gums are left to heal, and impressions are taken once the ridge has settled. The denture then goes through the usual steps, including a wax try-in where you can see and approve the look before it is finished. It fits the healed mouth, so early adjustments are usually fewer.

Side by side
| Point | Same-day (immediate) | Conventional |
|---|---|---|
| When it goes in | The day of the extractions | After the gums have healed |
| Time without teeth | None | Some weeks, unless a temporary is worn |
| Try-in of the final look | Limited, as natural teeth are still present | Yes, with a wax try-in |
| Early fit | Loosens as healing progresses | Made to the healed shape |
| Follow-up visits | More in the first months, with linings and relines | Fewer early on |
| Longer term | Often replaced by a new denture after healing | Relined or replaced as the ridge changes over the years |
Healing is what drives the difference
An extraction site keeps changing for months. A study by Schropp and colleagues (International Journal of Periodontics and Restorative Dentistry, 2003) found that the major changes happen during the first year after extraction. Better Health Victoria notes that a denture may need adjusting and relining within a few months of teeth being removed, and the Australian Dental Association says an immediate denture may need more follow-up appointments and may need replacing sooner.
So a same-day denture is less a finished product than a well-planned first stage. A conventional denture skips that stage, at the price of waiting.
Which one tends to suit whom
Same-day dentures often suit people having front teeth removed, people whose work or family life means they cannot go without teeth, and anyone who would find a gap too distressing. Conventional dentures often suit people who can manage a healing period, want to see and approve the finished look first, and would rather have fewer adjustment visits.
Many people combine the two: an immediate denture through healing, then a new conventional denture made to the settled ridge, with the first one kept as a spare. If only a few teeth are being replaced, a partial denture or a flipper tooth may be more fitting than a full denture.
What the appointments look like
For a same-day denture, most of the work happens before the extractions: impressions, bite records and choosing tooth shade and shape. The extraction visit ends with the denture being fitted, and reviews follow within days, then over the following weeks and months as the gums change.
For a conventional denture, the extractions come first and the denture visits start once the gums have healed. These usually include impressions, a custom-tray impression, bite records, a wax try-in and the fit, followed by a review or two for sore spots. If you have teeth removed and choose to wait, ask whether a simple temporary is possible for the healing period, particularly for front teeth.
How the costs compare
The denture itself is usually priced in a similar range either way. Typical market ranges are about $1,000 to $5,000 for a full denture for one arch, and about $2,000 to $7,000 for a full upper and lower set. A same-day denture often adds cost over the first year through linings, relines or a replacement denture. These are typical market ranges, not Lumi Dental fees. Medicare does not generally cover dentures for adults, and extras cover rebates vary by fund; our guide to dental cover in Australia explains how extras work, and our denture cost guide lists ranges by type.
Common questions
Does a same-day denture hurt more?
Most of the discomfort comes from the extraction sites healing, not the denture. An immediate denture can rub more in the early weeks as the gums change, and short adjustment visits help.
Can I switch to a conventional denture later?
Yes. Many people wear the immediate denture through healing and then have a new one made, or have the first one relined if it still suits.
How many relines will I need?
It varies with how much the gums and bone change. Your dentist will check the fit at reviews and suggest a lining or reline when it is needed.
Can I go straight to implants instead?
Sometimes. Implants can hold a snap-in denture or a fixed bridge, and in some cases they are placed when teeth are removed. A 3D X-ray and examination show whether that is possible.
Next step
The choice usually comes down to which teeth are being removed, your gum health and how much a healing period would affect your life. The Lumi Dental team can explain both options for your mouth, and you will usually receive a written treatment plan, often by email. Check current deals or book with our general dentists.









