Fluoride varnish, silver diamine fluoride (SDF) and a filling are not three versions of the same treatment. Varnish is mainly used for prevention and for early decay that has not yet made a hole. SDF is painted onto a cavity to help stop the decay without drilling, and it stains the decayed area black. A filling replaces the missing tooth structure. Which one suits a child's tooth depends partly on how far the decay has gone, and partly on practical questions covered below.
This article compares the three using the trials and reviews behind them, and sets out the practical questions families and dentists weigh up. For background on SDF itself, see our article on silver diamine fluoride.
The stage of the decay points to the starting option
healthdirect, a government-funded health information service, explains that decay which has not yet made a hole can be treated by a dental professional with fluoride paste or varnish, alongside brushing with fluoride toothpaste and changes to diet, and that a filling may be needed to restore the tooth's structure.
A network meta-analysis led by researchers at the American Dental Association's Science Institute compared non-restorative treatments across 44 trials. Study-level data suggested that 5% sodium fluoride varnish was the most effective option for arresting or reversing early, non-cavitated decay on the cheek and tongue sides of teeth (low certainty). For stopping advanced cavities on any crown surface, study-level data suggested that 38% SDF applied twice a year was the most effective option (moderate to high certainty) (Urquhart and colleagues, Journal of Dental Research, 2019).
In broad terms, the evidence lines up like this:
| Option | What it is mainly for | What to expect |
|---|---|---|
| Fluoride varnish | Early decay that has not yet made a hole | Painted on, no drilling |
| Silver diamine fluoride | Stopping an existing cavity from progressing | Painted on, no drilling; the decayed area turns black |
| Filling | Restoring the structure of a tooth that has a cavity | Rebuilds the missing part of the tooth |
SDF compared with fluoride varnish
The 2024 Cochrane review of SDF found eight trials comparing it with fluoride varnish. For preventing new decay in baby teeth, SDF may make little or no difference compared with varnish (one trial, low-certainty evidence). For stopping existing decay in baby teeth, the reviewers were unsure whether either was better, because the evidence came from one trial and was very low certainty (Worthington and colleagues, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2024).
A large trial published since then enrolled 752 children aged 3 to 4 in Bogotá and Cartagena, Colombia (611 completed the one-year follow-up), who received either 38% SDF or 5% varnish twice a year. After one year, SDF was not inferior to varnish for preventing new cavities, with an average of 0.40 new cavity surfaces per child with SDF and 0.61 with varnish. Active cavities were arrested in 72.2% of children in the SDF group and 49.4% in the varnish group, a difference that was not statistically significant. Most parents in both groups were satisfied (Martignon and colleagues, Caries Research, 2026).
In a smaller split-mouth trial of 43 preschool children with early decay between the back baby teeth, a single application of 30% SDF stopped progression in 74.4% of lesions and 5% varnish in 67.5% over six months, a difference that was not significant (Motallebi and colleagues, Saudi Dental Journal, 2025).
Taken together, varnish can be a sound choice for prevention and early decay, and SDF is not clearly better at preventing new cavities. The strongest review support for SDF is for stopping cavities that are already there, although head-to-head evidence against varnish for this is still uncertain. Our article on fluoride varnish for children explains how varnish is applied and how often.
SDF compared with a filling
A 2026 meta-analysis pooled seven randomised trials of more than 8,000 children that compared SDF with restorative treatment in baby teeth, including atraumatic restorative treatment (a filling placed mainly with hand instruments) and glass ionomer-based fillings. It found no statistically significant difference in caries arrest. The trials varied so much that the authors said the result does not prove the two are equivalent. They suggested SDF may be practical when restorative treatment is difficult, and that the choice should also weigh the staining, the child's cooperation, the family's preferences and the need for repeat treatment (Chang and colleagues, Quintessence International, 2026).
In a separate trial of 68 children aged 2 to 5 in Rio de Janeiro, 30% SDF and atraumatic fillings arrested similar numbers of lesions on the biting surfaces of baby molars over 12 months, and SDF took much less chair time. Changes in anxiety, and adverse effects combined with parents' views on appearance, did not differ between the groups (Vollú and colleagues, Journal of Dentistry, 2019).
Fillings in baby teeth also vary in how long they last. An umbrella review found that atraumatic fillings did better in single-surface cavities (86% success over three years) than in cavities involving more than one surface (48.7% to 88%). The same review found that preformed metal crowns placed with the Hall technique were likely to reduce discomfort, pain and major failures compared with conventional fillings, although the data were limited (BaniHani and colleagues, European Archives of Paediatric Dentistry, 2022). Our article on Hall technique crowns explains that approach.
SDF and a filling can be combined
SDF can be applied first and a glass ionomer filling placed over it, an approach often called SMART. In a randomised trial in New Delhi of 226 children aged 4 to 8, glass ionomer fillings placed this way and fillings placed with the conventional drill-and-fill method had similar success at 24 months (38.4% and 45.8%, not a significant difference; 81.6% of the treated molars were checked at that point). Children accepted the SMART approach more readily: 79% compared with 56% (Bansal and colleagues, Journal of Dentistry, 2023). In this trial, fewer than half of the fillings in either group were rated successful at two years, so ongoing reviews matter whichever method is used. Our article on SMART fillings covers the appointments involved.
What families usually weigh up
The reviews above point to a handful of practical questions that often decide the choice:
- Is there a cavity, or is the decay still on the surface?
- Is the tooth at the front or the back, and how would the family feel about a black area? Our article on how families decide about the SDF stain looks at this in detail.
- How easily can the child manage drilling or numbing at this age?
- Does the tooth need its missing structure rebuilt?
- Can the family return for reviews and reapplications?
These are not either-or choices for good. A tooth might have SDF first and a filling placed over it, as in the SMART approach above, and varnish may still be used for prevention alongside either treatment. The American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry's guideline recommends 38% SDF to stop cavities in baby teeth as part of an overall caries management program, a conditional recommendation based on low-quality evidence (Crystal and colleagues, Pediatric Dentistry, 2017).
For dentists: match the agent to the lesion, and consider separators for early approximal lesions
The Urquhart network meta-analysis supports using lesion stage and site to choose the agent: 5% NaF varnish for non-cavitated facial and lingual lesions, and biannual 38% SDF for arresting advanced cavitated coronal lesions. Both findings come from study-level data rather than the network estimates, and the varnish finding is low certainty. For non-cavitated approximal lesions, the network meta-analysis favoured resin infiltration plus 5% NaF varnish (low to moderate certainty).
For early approximal lesions in primary molars, the Motallebi split-mouth trial placed elastic separators for three days to open the contact before a single application of 30% SDF or 5% NaF varnish, then assessed progression on bitewings at six months. Arrest was 74.4% with SDF and 67.5% with varnish, not significantly different. It was a small trial (50 enrolled, 43 analysed) with lesions confined to enamel or the outer third of dentine, 30% rather than 38% SDF, no untreated control and only six months of follow-up, so it suggests the technique is workable rather than showing that SDF is superior.
How this works at Lumi
Lumi Dental sees children from their first teeth. Our oral health therapists, Sabrina Tran and Jennifer Nguyen, see children and families and focus on prevention. Lumi offers SDF for suitable cases. SDF stains the decayed area black, and whether it suits a particular tooth is decided at the examination, along with the other options. Eligible children can be bulk billed under the Child Dental Benefits Schedule, which covers children aged 0 to 17 in eligible families with a benefit cap of $1,158 over two calendar years in 2026; see our CDBS page and our children's dentist page for details.
Questions parents ask
Is SDF just a stronger fluoride varnish?
Both contain fluoride, but they are used differently. Varnish is mainly used for prevention and early decay. SDF also contains silver and is mainly applied to decay that is already there, and it stains the decayed area black. In the trials above, SDF was not clearly better than varnish at preventing new cavities.
Does SDF mean my child will never need a filling?
Not necessarily. SDF aims to stop decay, not rebuild the tooth. A filling can still be placed on a tooth treated with SDF, including over the SDF, as in the SMART approach.
Which option hurts least?
Varnish and SDF are painted on, without drilling. The Cochrane review was unsure whether SDF and atraumatic fillings differ in pain or sensitivity, because the evidence was very low certainty. In the New Delhi trial, more children accepted SMART than conventional drill-and-fill treatment, and in the Rio de Janeiro trial SDF took less chair time than atraumatic fillings.
To have your child's teeth checked, book an appointment at Lumi Dental in Melrose Park.
Sources
- Worthington HV and colleagues. Topical silver diamine fluoride (SDF) for preventing and managing dental caries in children and adults. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2024. PubMed 39508296
- Urquhart O and colleagues. Nonrestorative treatments for caries: systematic review and network meta-analysis. Journal of Dental Research, 2019. PubMed 30290130
- Martignon S and colleagues. Cavity management effectiveness and feasibility of silver diamine fluoride solution and sodium fluoride varnish in children: one-year follow-up non-inferiority randomised controlled trial. Caries Research, 2026. PubMed 40267887
- Motallebi A and colleagues. Silver diamine fluoride versus sodium fluoride varnish in the treatment of proximal caries in primary molars: a randomized clinical trial. Saudi Dental Journal, 2025. PubMed 40397187
- Chang P and colleagues. Silver diamine fluoride versus conventional restorative treatment for dental caries in primary teeth of children: a meta-analysis. Quintessence International, 2026. PubMed 42405802
- Vollú AL and colleagues. Efficacy of 30% silver diamine fluoride compared to atraumatic restorative treatment on dentine caries arrestment in primary molars of preschool children. Journal of Dentistry, 2019. PubMed 31279925
- BaniHani A and colleagues. Minimal intervention dentistry for managing carious lesions into dentine in primary teeth: an umbrella review. European Archives of Paediatric Dentistry, 2022. PubMed 34784027
- Bansal K and colleagues. Silver diamine fluoride modified atraumatic restorative treatment compared to conventional restorative technique on carious primary molars: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Dentistry, 2023. PubMed 37704105
- Crystal YO and colleagues. Use of silver diamine fluoride for dental caries management in children and adolescents, including those with special health care needs. Pediatric Dentistry, 2017. PubMed 29070149
- healthdirect. Tooth decay. healthdirect.gov.au









