Most people who dread impressions remember the same thing: a tray of cold putty pushed up against the back of the mouth, and a few minutes of trying not to gag while it sets. A digital scan takes away the tray and the waiting. A small camera is moved over the teeth instead, and you can stop at any point.
For most routine work the finished crown, aligner or guard fits as well either way, so the practical difference is how the appointment feels. There are still a few situations where a conventional impression is the better tool.
What happens in the chair with each method
With a conventional impression, the dentist chooses a tray, fills it with putty or silicone, seats it over your teeth and holds it still until the material sets. It comes out as a negative copy of your teeth, which is disinfected, packed and sent to a lab to be poured into a model.
With a scan, a slim wand with a small camera in its tip is moved slowly along the biting surfaces, then the cheek side and tongue side of each tooth. The camera captures a stream of images that software joins into a 3D model, and you can usually watch it build on the screen. A scan of the bite is added at the end so the upper and lower models line up.
Gagging is the main reason people ask for a scan
The tray sits furthest back in the mouth on the upper arch, close to the soft palate, and it has to stay put while the material sets. That is when most people gag. A scanner tip is slim, moves around rather than staying in one spot, and can be lifted out the moment you need a break.
Research on patient experience points the same way. A 2026 systematic review of adult studies in Frontiers in Oral Health (Ramos-Morro and colleagues) found digital impressions were consistently reported as faster and more comfortable, though only a few studies measured comfort directly. A 2026 meta-analysis in children (Garcovich and colleagues, International Journal of Paediatric Dentistry) found scanning was quicker and caused less gagging and breathing difficulty, and children were more than four times as likely to prefer it.
If you gag easily, say so when you book. The appointment can be planned with extra time and breaks, and our guide to managing a strong gag reflex at the dentist covers other techniques that help.
If part of the record is unclear
A conventional impression with an air bubble or a drag mark in the wrong place usually has to be taken again from the start, sometimes after the lab has already received it. With a scan, the dentist can see gaps or blurry areas on screen straight away and rescan just that part. Once it is approved, the file is sent electronically, so nothing can warp or be damaged on the way to the lab.
Accuracy is similar for most everyday work
Scanner marketing often suggests digital is far more accurate. The evidence is more measured. A 2025 overview of 28 systematic reviews in the Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry (Kaitatzidou and colleagues) found no statistically significant difference in accuracy or fit between scans and conventional impressions for crowns, short bridges and implant restorations, with conventional impressions doing better for complete-arch bridges.
In real conditions, both methods depend on technique. A scanner needs a clear line of sight, so saliva, blood and soft tissue in the way can blur the record. Putty can be spoiled by bubbles, movement or poor mixing. Our companion article on digital impressions and traditional moulds for different treatments goes through crowns, implants, aligners and dentures one at a time.
When putty is still the better choice
Full dentures
A full denture sits on gum, and some impression techniques deliberately record the soft tissue at the edges as the cheeks and tongue move. A 2026 scoping review in the Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry (Mohamedin and colleagues) found scanners struggle with toothless ridges, which have few landmarks and movable tissue at the borders, and concluded there is not yet reliable evidence that scans can fully replace conventional impressions for complete dentures. Our denture cost guide explains how the different types of denture are made.
Edges hidden under bleeding gum
When the edge of a crown preparation sits below the gumline and the gum is inflamed, the camera cannot see the margin it needs to record. Settling the gum first is usually the better answer, and our article on why gums bleed when brushing explains how that is done.

Cost, radiation and other practical points
The way a record is taken does not usually change what you pay; the fee depends on the treatment itself. You will usually receive a written treatment plan after your examination, often by email, and current offers are on our current deals page.
An intraoral scanner is an optical camera. It does not use X-rays and involves no ionising radiation. X-rays are a separate record taken for a different reason, explained in our guide to bitewing and OPG X-rays.
At Lumi Dental, a 3D intraoral scanner is used for most records, including crowns and onlays, implant crowns, clear aligners, mouthguards and night guards. A 3D model on the screen also makes it easier to show you what the dentist is looking at. If you are comparing restoration options, our article on inlays, onlays, crowns and fillings may help.
Questions we are often asked
Does a scan hurt?
No. You feel the smooth tip of the wand touching the teeth and gums as it moves, and the dentist can stop whenever you need a break.
How long does a scan take?
Usually a few minutes per arch, plus a short bite scan. Upper, lower and bite records generally fit comfortably within a normal appointment.
Is it a concern if my dentist uses putty?
No. Conventional impressions are well established and still the preferred option in some cases. It is reasonable to ask which method suits your treatment and why.
This article is general information only and is not a substitute for personal dental advice. Every mouth is different, and the right approach for you depends on an examination by a registered dental practitioner.
If a bad impression experience has made you put off a crown, a mouthguard or aligner records, ask about a scan. Our dentists at Lumi Dental in Melrose Park can explain what your treatment involves. See our current deals page or read more about our general dentistry team.









