Book Online

All health funds accepted · Payment plans available, humm from $0 deposit · CDBS bulk billing

All health funds accepted · Payment plans available, humm from $0 deposit · CDBS bulk billing

Book online

A treatment room at Lumi Dental

THE LUMI BLOG

Amalgam filling removal: is it safe and when is it worth doing?

Sound amalgam fillings can usually stay in place, but decay, cracks or a weakened tooth are good reasons to replace one, using protective steps to limit mercury exposure.

Dr James Tran, dentist at Lumi Dental Melrose Park

Dr James Tran

October 3, 2026 · Patient Education · 5 min read

An old silver filling that is intact, sealed at the edges and causing no problems can usually stay where it is and be checked at your regular visits. Taking it out will not detox the body, and it costs the tooth some healthy structure each time. Replacement makes sense when there is a dental reason, such as decay around the filling, a crack, or a tooth that is at risk of breaking.

Why the mercury question keeps coming up

Amalgam is made by mixing liquid mercury with a powder of silver, tin and copper. It sets into a hard, long-wearing filling, and once set the mercury is bound within the alloy. Very small amounts of vapour can be released, for example with chewing or grinding, which is why the material attracts concern.

The Australian Dental Association's policy on dental amalgam states that it remains a safe and acceptable restorative option where clinically indicated. Separately, the Minamata Convention on Mercury is an international agreement to reduce mercury use, largely for environmental reasons. Under it, amalgam can now be used only in pre-dosed capsules, and the ADA policy notes that 2034 has been set as the global phase-out date for its manufacture, import and export. A phase-down driven by environmental concerns is a different question from whether the fillings already in your mouth are harming you. Our article on whether silver amalgam fillings are safe looks at the research in more depth.

Replacing a sound filling does not improve general health

The ADA policy says there is no evidence that replacing sound amalgam fillings without a clinical reason improves health, and that they should not be removed for non-specific or perceived health complaints unless the patient has been fully informed of the risks and benefits. Drilling out a filling that is doing its job removes some of the surrounding tooth, so each replacement leaves the tooth a little weaker, and the drilling itself briefly increases mercury vapour near the mouth.

If you are dealing with tiredness, headaches, aches or other symptoms and suspect your fillings may be involved, please start with your GP. Those symptoms have many possible causes that deserve a proper medical assessment.

Signs a filling has reached the end of its life

Fillings wear out, whatever they are made of. Our article on how long fillings last explains why. Your dentist may recommend replacing an amalgam filling when there is:

  • decay underneath it or along its edge, often seen on X-rays
  • a crack in the filling or in the tooth around it
  • a chipped, worn or open margin that lets bacteria in
  • a large filling that leaves thin walls of tooth at risk of splitting
  • a confirmed allergy or a lichenoid reaction in the cheek or gum next to it

Some people also want to replace visible silver fillings for appearance. That is a reasonable personal choice, as long as you understand that it uses up some tooth structure. Small edge defects are sometimes watched rather than treated straight away. A grey mark in the gum near an old filling is often an amalgam tattoo, which is harmless, although any new or changing dark patch should be checked; our article on amalgam tattoos explains them.

A clinician in blue scrubs, cap and mask examining the teeth of a patient lying back in the dental chair
An examination and X-rays show whether an old filling needs replacing or can simply be monitored.

How exposure is kept low during removal

When a filling does need to come out, dentists use steps to limit what the patient and the team are exposed to. These commonly include a rubber dam, a thin sheet that isolates the tooth so less material is swallowed or breathed in; high-volume suction held close to the tooth; plenty of water spray to keep the area cool; and cutting the filling into chunks rather than grinding it to fine dust. Dental practices are also expected to dispose of amalgam waste correctly, and many fit amalgam separators to their suction lines so waste does not enter the sewer. It is reasonable to ask which of these will be used at your appointment.

Choosing what goes in its place

The replacement depends on how much sound tooth remains once the old filling and any decay are removed. A tooth-coloured composite filling suits many small to medium cavities. Glass ionomer is useful in particular situations, explained in our article on when dentists use glass ionomer. Where a larger part of the tooth needs rebuilding, an inlay or onlay may protect it better, as set out in our guide to inlays, onlays, crowns and fillings, and a heavily broken-down tooth may need a crown, as discussed in when a filling needs to become a crown.

A treatment room at Lumi Dental with a 3D scan of a patient's teeth displayed on the screen
A 3D scan of the teeth can help when an onlay or crown is being designed to replace a large old filling.

For a direct comparison of the two most common filling materials, see white versus silver fillings.

Pregnancy, breastfeeding, children and kidney disease

The ADA policy advises dentists to minimise the use of amalgam in children, in pregnant or breastfeeding women and in people with kidney disease. Removing sound amalgam fillings is also generally avoided during pregnancy, since it brings no dental benefit and can briefly increase mercury vapour exposure. A tooth that is painful, infected or breaking can still be treated, and your dentist can discuss timing and materials with you and your doctor. Our guide to dental care during pregnancy has more detail.

Allergy and lichenoid reactions

A proven allergy to amalgam or one of its components is uncommon. Lichenoid reactions, white lacy or red sore patches in the cheek or gum touching a filling, are also seen occasionally. If you notice these, see your dentist, who may refer you for testing or to an oral medicine practitioner. Replacing the filling with another material may be advised if a reaction is confirmed. Our article on allergic reactions to dental materials explains the signs.

Questions about old silver fillings

Should I have all my amalgam fillings replaced at once?

Not without a dental reason for each one. Fillings are assessed individually, and sound ones are usually left alone.

Is it safe to have an amalgam filling taken out?

Yes, when there is a clinical reason and protective steps such as a rubber dam and high-volume suction are used.

Will a white filling last as long?

Composite fillings can last many years with good care, though both materials eventually wear. Your dentist can explain which suits a particular tooth and bite.

If you would like your fillings checked, our team at Lumi Dental in Melrose Park can examine them, take X-rays where needed and explain the options. Read about our general dentistry services, see current offers on our current deals page, or get a general idea of costs from our dental filling cost guide.

Dr James Tran, dentist at Lumi Dental, Melrose Park

Written by Dr James Tran

Dr James Tran (BDent, University of Sydney; Graduate Diploma in Oral Implants) is a general dentist at Lumi Dental in Melrose Park. The team writes these articles to give clear, evidence-based dental information to help you make informed decisions about your care.

Inside Lumi Dental, Melrose Park

New patients

Your first visit is $149

A full 60 minute first visit with a check-up, clean, X-rays and a treatment plan. Usually $654, offer ends 31 December 2026. With most health funds there is no gap.

Open Monday to Saturday, and until 9:30pm on Thursdays. Free undercover parking at Melrose Central.